Thursday, February 11, 2010

"REPORTABLE"

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.1026 OF 2008


Dilip Premnarayan Tiwari & Anr. .... Appellants

Versus

State of Maharashtra .... Respondent

WITH

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.1025 OF 2008

Sunil Ramashray Yadav .....Appellant

Versus

State of Maharashtra ....Respondent

J U D G M E N T

V.S. SIRPURKAR, J.


1. This judgment will dispose of two appeals, they being

Criminal Appeal No.1026 of 2008, filed on behalf of the appellant

accused Dilip Premnarayan Tiwari and Manoj Paswan, as also

Criminal Appeal No.1025 of 2008 filed by Sunil Ramashray Yadav.

Their appeals against their convictions by the Sessions Judge have

been dismissed by the Bombay High Court and the death sentence

awarded to all the three accused has also been confirmed.

2. As many as five accused persons were tried by the Trial

Court for offences under Section 302, 307, 452 read with Section

120B of the Indian Penal Code (`IPC' for short) and Section 34 and

Section 120B, IPC (substantive). Eventually, original accused No.

4, Premnarayan Brijkishore Tiwari and accused No.5 Tulsa Devi were
acquitted by the Trial Court whereas the other three accused

persons, namely, accused No.1, Dilip Premnarayan Tiwari, accused

No.2, Sunil Ramashray Yadav and accused No.3, Manoj Tulshi Paswan

were convicted under different Sections for various offences

including Section 302 read with Section 34, Section 307 read with

Section 34, IPC and Section 452 read with Section 34 of the IPC.

While they were awarded death sentence for the offence under

Section 302, they were awarded 10 years' rigorous imprisonment

with fine of Rs. 5,000/- each, and in default, to suffer 5 month's

imprisonment each for offence under Section 307 read with Section

34, IPC and three year's rigorous imprisonment and to pay a fine

of Rs. 1,000/- each, in default, to suffer one month's

imprisonment.


3. Since it was a death sentence matter, reference was made to

the High Court for the confirmation of the death sentence and the

accused also filed appeals against their conviction and the

punishment therefor before the High Court. The High Court has

confirmed the death sentence while the appeals of the accused

persons were dismissed. That is how these two appeals have come

before us.


4. As per the prosecution case, accused No.1, Dilip

Premnarayan Tiwari, is the son of original accused No. 4,

Premnarayan Brijkishore Tiwari, and original accused No. 5, Tulsa

Devi is the wife of accused No.4. Accused No.1, Dilip's sister

Sushma fell in love with deceased Prabhu who used to live in the

neighbourhood of their residential house. Ultimately, she got
married to Prabhu. Prabhu being a Keralite and belonging to

`Ezhava' caste, the marriage was not approved of by the family of

Sushma since Sushma belonged to a Brahmin caste from the State of

Uttar Pradesh. The whole family of Sushma was extremely opposed

to the marriage which took place on 29.10.2003 before the

Registrar of Marriages, Bandra, Mumbai. According to the

prosecution, there were efforts to call back Sushma into her

familyfold. According to the prosecution, she was threatened and

so were her in-laws by original accused No.1, Dilip.


5. The love affair of Sushma with deceased Prabhu was going on

for about 5-6 years and deceased Abhayraj @ Bachhu and Bijit used

to act as messengers between the two. They were also threatened

during the love affair by Dilip as well as his mother, original

accused No.5, Tulsa Devi. According to the prosecution, accused

Dilip had assaulted Sushma with kicks and fist blows on account of

her love affair with Prabhu and had also threatened that in case

she married Prabhu, both will be eliminated. However, as has been

stated earlier, the marriage took place on 29.10.2003 and after

the marriage Sushma started residing with her husband, deceased

Prabhu. She was a college going girl at the time of her marriage

and she continued her education even after her marriage. Accused

No. 5, Tulsa Devi also advised her to leave Prabhu. She also

promised her that her second marriage would be arranged in Uttar

Pradesh. Her elder sister Kalpana, who is already married had

also tried to contact Sushma and had come to the house of Sushma

to meet her. She had also met Sushma on 08.05.2004 in her college

and tried to persuade her that her husband was not smart and was
not earning anything and, therefore, she should accompany her to

their hometown in Uttar Pradesh where they had selected one youth

serving in the Air Force and that Sushma should marry him. Sushma

straightaway refused all these proposals. In fact, on account of

these threats, Sushma had suggested that a police complaint should

be lodged against Tiwari family. However, she was assured by her

husband Prabhu that everything would be alright with the passage

of time. There were even proposals that on account of the

threats, Sushma and Prabhu should leave Bombay and stay in his

hometown in Kerala. However, instead of doing that, Sushma, who

was pregnant at that time, was sent to Prabhu's relative's house

in Andheri and that is how Sushma was shifted to the house of

Shashidharan, PW-2. Shashidharan's wife was the sister of

Prabhu's mother, Indira. One Balan, PW-1 also used to live in

Andheri. His wife was the third real sister of Prabhu's mother,

Indira.


6. The ghastly incident took place on the night of 16/17th May,

2004. On that day, Prabhu's father Krishnan Nochil himself, his

nephew Bijit, Prabhu's sister, Deepa (PW-4) and Indira (PW-8) were

present in the Noichil household. At about 1.15 a.m. at night

someone knocked the back side door of their house. Deceased

Krishnan Nochil opened the door. According to the prosecution,

the three appellants, namely, Dilip (A-1), Manoj (A-3) and Sunil

(A-2) and one more unknown person entered the house. Dilip and

Manoj assaulted Krishnan Nochil with knife over the chest, stomach

and when Prabhu rushed to save his father, accused No. 1, Dilip

and accused No. 3, Manoj assaulted him also with knife and stabbed
him in stomach and chest. As per the prosecution case, Dilip

asked Sunil and one unknown person to take Prabhu out of the house

and kill him. When Deepa (PW-4) started proceeding ahead to save

her brother, Dilip and Manoj rushed towards her with knife and at

that time Bijit who had come there caught hold of accused Manoj

and urged him not to assault her. At that time accused Manoj

inflicted blows with knife over hand, chest and cheek of Bijit as

a result of which Bijit fell down. The accused Dilip and Manoj

came near Deepa and inflicted blows with knife on her face and

body and when Deepa fell down, Indira, Prabhu's mother who was

awakened, tried to intervene. At that time, she was also

assaulted by Dilip (accused No.1) and Manoj (accused No.3). At

that time, Sunil who had gone out along with the unknown assailant

came back and inflicted knife blows over the neck of Abhayraj @

Bachhu who had in the meantime come there. Abhayraj was the

immediate neighbour and used to live in between the houses of

Tiwari household and Noichil household. Having been assaulted, he

ran outside when Sunil (original accused No.2) chased him and

assaulted him also. Accused Dilip and Manoj then left the house

and while leaving, Manoj had dropped the knife in that room.

Deepa who was severely injured gathered her courage and after 10-

15 minutes of the assault contacted PW-1, Balan on phone and

informed him about the incident of assault at the instance of

accused No.1 Dilip, accused No.3 Manoj and accused No, 2 Sunil and

one more person. Indira, mother of Prabhu who was also seriously

injured somehow opened the front door and shouted `bachao bachao'.


7. At this time Prabhu was lying in an injured condition in
front of the door and was shouting `mummy mummy''. Balan (PW-1),

on receiving the phone call in the dead of night from Deepa,

rushed to the Noichil household in Khairpada Waliv at about 4'O

clock in the morning only to find that his son Bijit and brother-

in-law Krishnan Nochil were dead and lying in the pool of blood

while Deepa, Indira and Prabhu who were alive, were shifted to the

local dispensary by Head Constable Bhosale who was on bandobast

duty at check post, Sativali Khind, who had rushed to the spot on

being informed. Bhosale had also sent a message to Manikpur

Police Station to send one mobile van. Bhosale also brought one

tempo and arranged to send the three injured to Primary Health

Centre, Navghar.


8. By that time, Balan who was informed by Deepa had contacted

Shashidharan and come to Navghar along with Shashidharan.

Thereafter, all the injured were taken to one Bhagvati hospital as

they were very seriously injured and could not have been treated

in the Primary Health Centre at Navghar. Deepa and Indira were

not in a condition to speak, however, Prabhu disclosed to

Shashidharan who was accompanying them in the mobile van that

Sushma's brother Dilip, Manoj and Sunil and one more person had

inflicted knife blows and had injured him and other persons of the

family.


9. The injured Prabhu reached Bhagvati hospital along with

Shashidharan in the mobile van and there he also succumbed to his

injuries. Deepa had lost her consciousness while Indira was also

very seriously injured and they were treated in the Hospital. But
before that, at about 5 a.m. Balan came to the police station and

lodged the First Information Report which was registered as

C.R.No. 1-144/04 registered at about 5.30 a.m. for the offence

under Section 302 and 307, 452 read with Section 34 of the IPC.

The police reached the spot and PSI Shri Bharve prepared the

inquest Panchnama of the dead bodies of Krishnan Nochil and Bijit.

He also prepared the inquest Panchnama of Abhayraj who was lying

outside the house near K.T.Maidan and, thereafter, all the three

dead bodies were sent for post-mortem examination. Investigation

officer also prepared the spot Panchnama and seized blood stained

handkerchief, blood stained iron knife which were lying there and

also collected the blood samples lying on the floor. Deepa's

statement came to be recorded on 18.05.2004 after she regained

consciousness. Prabhu's body was also sent for post-mortem.


10. During the investigation, the statements of witnesses like

Sushma and Indira came to be recorded. Dilip was arrested on

29.5.2004 from Uttar Pradesh. One knife, pant and shirt having

blood stains were recovered at the instance of Dilip. Since

Indira was very seriously injured, her statement could be recorded

on 02.06.2004 in the Hospital. Accused Sunil came to be arrested

on 02.06.2004. He has also disclosed on 05.06.2004 about the

knife and the blood stained clothes which were seized. Accused

No.2, Manoj came to be arrested only on 22.06.2004 while the

parents of Dilip (original accused No.1), Premnarayan Tiwari

(original accused No. 4) and Tulsa Devi (original accused No.5)

were also arrested on 25.6.2004. After the completion of the

investigation the charge sheet was filed against five named
accused and on that basis charges were framed against all the

accused persons. The Trial Court, however, acquitted original

accused Nos.4 and 5 since they had not taken part in the dastardly

attack and the charge of conspiracy under Section 120B, IPC also

was not proved against them, but awarded death sentence to the

remaining accused and that is how the matter has come before us.


11. Shri Gaurav Agrawal, Advocate appeared for accused No.1,

Dilip and accused No. 3, Manoj and Shri S.N. Raj, Advocate

appeared for accused No.2, Sunil while the State of Maharashtra

was represented by Shri Sushil Karanjkar, Advocate. Shri Gaurav

Agrawal attacked the findings of the Trial Court and the High

Court in respect of both the accused persons. The mainstay of his

argument was that the whole prosecution case stood on extremely

weak basis inasmuch as all the prosecution witnesses were

interested witnesses and as such it was very risky to rely on the

evidence of those witnesses. Learned counsel severely attacked

the so-called oral dying declaration by deceased Prabhu alleged to

have been made by him in the Ambulance Van to Shashidharan (PW-2).

Learned counsel argues that Prabhu who was severely injured and

who died barely within few hours of his reaching the Hospital

could not be said to be in the proper physical condition to make a

dying declaration. The counsel, therefore, urged that the

acceptance of such a weak piece of evidence for corroborating the

prosecution evidence could not be accepted. The learned counsel

also invited our attention to the fact that though from the

beginning, the case of the prosecution was that there were, in

all, four accused persons; the fourth accused person besides the
three appellants could neither be identified nor brought before

the law. Therefore, the whole prosecution case had become

mysterious. As regards the evidence of the eye witnesses, the

learned counsel pointed out that the said evidence of Deepa (PW-4)

and Indira (PW-8) was unnatural, apart from the fact that it was

riddled with material contradictions and omissions and was

contradictory inter se. The learned counsel also commented upon

the medical evidence suggesting that the said evidence was not

commensurate with the eye witness account. As regards the rest of

the circumstantial evidence, the learned counsel pointed out that

it was not trustworthy. Insofar as the verdict of the High Court

in confirming death sentence was concerned, the learned counsel

urged that this was not a rarest of rare case though as much as

four persons had lost their lives.


12. Shri Raj, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the

accused No.2, Sunil adopted the arguments of Shri Agrawal insofar

as they pertained to the evidence of the eye witnesses as also the

other aspects of the case. However, Shri Raj invited our

attention to the fact that after reaching the Hospital, the

deceased Prabhu had made a dying declaration which was recorded by

Doctor Shri S.S. Anakal (PW-5). He pointed out that the said

dying declaration was counter signed by the Investigating Officers

and the said dying declaration also bore the thumb impression of

deceased Prabhu Krishnan Nochil. Learned counsel further pointed

out that this dying declaration formed part of the charge-sheet

and was supplied to the accused persons along with the same. He

further pointed out that though this dying declaration was not put
to the witness, Dr. Anakal (PW-5) during the Trial before the

Sessions Judge, an application to that effect was filed before the

High Court and the High Court rejected the same. Learned counsel

issued a notice under Section 294 (2) Cr.P.C. to the Public

Prosecutor to admit this document whereupon the Public Prosecution

has admitted the said document. According to the learned counsel,

therefore, the non-consideration of the said dying declaration

very seriously prejudiced at least accused No.2, Sunil whose name

was not to be found in the said dying declaration. Learned

counsel, therefore, urged that the participation of Sunil (accused

No.2) was highly suspicious, more particularly, in view of the

fact that the identity of Sunil was not established by the

prosecution either by holding Test Identification Parade or even

in the Court hall as the witnesses had not specifically identified

the accused persons individually. Shri Raj also urged that the

absence of Sunil's name in the First Information Report given by

Balan (PW-1) speaks volumes and was not realized by the Courts

below. Shri Raj further urged that there was no reason for the

Courts below to presume that Sunil Yadav was a friend of Dilip and

Manoj as there was no evidence brought on record regarding their

acquaintance and even the prosecution had not collected any

evidence to establish the nexus between accused No.2, Sunil and

the other two accused persons. Shri Raj, therefore, argued that

accused Sunil was bound to be given the benefit of doubt.


13. It has come in evidence of Deepa (PW-4) that immediately

after the incident, though injured seriously, she managed to call

Balan (PW-1) on his landline and narrated the incident to him.
She undoubtedly claims that she had taken the names of Dilip (A1),

Manoj (A-3) and Sunil (A-2) as also one more person as the persons

who had assaulted her family members and herself. Because of the

presence of mind of Deepa to call Balan, Balan immediately went

into action and firstly contacted Shashidharan (PW-2), also a

resident of Andheri as Balan. Both these witnesses were related

to the family inasmuch as while Balan is the husband of PW-8,

Indira's sister, Shashidharan is the husband of Balan's wife's

sister meaning that she is the third sister of Indira though Balan

does not specifically say so in his evidence. Shashidharan

deposed that he was woken up by Balan at about 1.30 a.m. and was

told that Dilip, Manoj and Sunil along with their associate had

assaulted the members of Nochil family. Significantly enough,

Sushma, wife of deceased Prabhu was also at that time present in

his household, she having come to his house for staying allegedly

on account of the threats given to her by Dilip. Shashidharan

then seems to have contacted his brother Gopal Krishnan and with

his help contacted Vasai Police Station and informed about the

incident. However, he was informed by Vasai Police Station that

Waliv Kherpada where incident had taken place comes within the

jurisdiction of Manikpur Police Station. According to this

witness, he narrated this incident to Manikpur Police Station by

calling them but they refused and instead asked them to contact

Waliv Police Station.Thus, they left Andheri at about 3 a.m. and

reached the spot of occurrence Waliv at about 4 a.m. After

reaching there they came to know that the injured Deepa and Indira

along with injured Prabhu had been sent to the Primary Health
Cenre of Wasai. The claim of Shashidharan (PW-2) is that he and

Balan reached Manikpur Police Station at about 5 a.m. where Balan

lodged the complaint. We have seen the said report made by Balan

vide Exbt. P-27. It is to be seen specifically that in that

report he informed that Deepa Nochil had informed him at about

1.15 a.m. on 17.05.2004 that Dilip who was the brother of her

sister-in-law Sushma and his three associates had trespassed into

the house and had beaten all the inmates and had also given knife

blows to them and they still were engaged in assault and,

therefore, Balan should come as early as possible to Vasai.

Significantly enough, the names of accused Manoj and accused Sunil

are not to be seen in this report. It has also come in the report

that since Dilip and his family members did not approve of love

marriage of Sushma with Prabhu and inspite of their opposition

Sushma had married Prabhu; hence Dilip and his associates had

given blows with sharp weapon to his brother-in-law Krishnan,

sister-in-law Indira, her daughter Deepa, her son Prabhu and his

son, Bijit. It was also pointed out that Krishnan and Bijit had

died in the attack and Indira, her dauther Deepa and her son

Prabhu were seriously injured and were taken to the dispensary.

Though in his evidence Balan (PW-1) insisted that he had also told

the names of Dilip (A-1), Manoj (A-3) and Sunil (A-2), the names

of Manoj and Sunil are not to be found in the FIR. Though there

was a reference that Dilip (A-1) was accompanying three other

associates, the witness was specific in asserting that from the

spot of occurrence he did not go directly to the dispensary but

went to the Police Station first.
14. The further significant thing about the FIR is that there

is no reference to the death of Abhayraj who had also lost his

life. It is slightly unusual that though this witness as per his

admission knew Abhayraj, there is no reference of the name of

Abhayraj in the FIR. Shri Gaurav Agrawal, learned counsel tried to

take advantage of this and pointed out that the name of Manoj (A-

3) was not to be found in the FIR and that advantage must go to

Manoj on that account. It is also seen that the witness had also

failed to speak about the body of Abhayraj. In our opinion,

though the omission of names of Manoj and Sunil is significant,

much importance cannot be given to this omission. The FIR was

after all given by a person who had seen the body of his young son

having been brutally murdered. He had also seen the dead body of

his brother-in-law and had also come to know that the other three

members of the family of Krishnan were also seriously injured in

the incident. The witness is bound to be excited and some scope

would have to be given to the mental state of the witness at that

time. The significance of this omission will be considered when

we individually consider the case of each accused. The Trial

Court as well as the High Court have not attached much importance

to this omission and rightly so. However, the fact must be noted

at this juncture that though this witness PW-1, Balan had come to

know about the role played by Manoj (A-3) and Sunil (A-2), their

names were not mentioned in the report. After these two persons

went to the Primary Health Centre from the Police Station an

Ambulance was called as all the three injured persons were in a

serious condition and possibly could not have been treated in the
Primary Health Centre and, therefore, they had to be shifted to

the other Hospital.


15. At that time, during the journey to the hospital, Prabhu is

stated to be conscious and had told the names of Dilip, Manoj and

Sunil to Shashidharan who was accompanying the injured in the

Ambulance Van. That is the claim of Shashidharan (PW-2). As per

his claim, Prabhu had taken the names of Dilip, Manoj and Sunil

and one more person as the persons who had inflicted blows with

knife on Prabhu. The witness described Manoj (A-3) and Sunil (A-

2) as the friends of Dilip (A-1). The witness was candid enough

to tell that he did not know them personally and further claimed

that Prabhu had told him that they were Dilip's friends. His

statement was recorded on 17.05.2004 in the evening. He denied

and was contradicted on the question of Balan's wife accompanying

them. However, he asserted further that the wife of Balan was not

accompanying them. That, in our opinion, is an insignificant

contradiction. Other omissions were also proved in the evidence

but they are all insignificant omissions. Sushma was allegedly

present at the time when Balan came to her house and a suggestion

was given to him that they enquired from Sushma about the names of

Manoj and Sunil. He, of course, refuted this suggestion. He was

candid enough to admit that he did not know the names of fathers

and surnames of Manoj and Sunil. He had not even seen Manoj and

Sunil till then. He deposed in the Court that he had never gone

to the house of Dilip at any time nor talked to any of his family

members. There is a significant omission in his statement to the

effect that he admitted that he had not stated before the police
that Sushma's brother Dilip, Manoj, Sunil and one more person

inflicted blows with knife. He also asserted that he had not

stated that Prabhu had told him that Manoj and Sunil were Dilip's

friends. It was specifically suggested that Prabhu had never

disclosed him about Manoj and Sunil being Dilip's friends. It was

also suggested that Prabhu had not disclosed about the assault by

these three persons on Prabhu's family members. He obviously

refuted those suggestions.


16. From the evidence of these two important witnesses one of

whom was the author of the FIR what transpires is that while the

role played by Dilip has been reflected in the FIR, the roles

played by Manoj and Sunil are not to be seen as reflected in the

FIR. Even as regards the alleged disclosure by deceased Prabhu to

this witness in the Ambulance Van would depend upon the evidence

of Deepa and Indira who were also present in the same van.


17. When we see the evidence of Deepa, it is seen that she was

an injured witness. As per the evidence of PW-9, Dr. Mahendra

Chandak, Deepa had suffered as many as four contused lacerated

wounds over right side of upper and lower lip, left shoulder, left

lumber region with omentum protruding out and over left gluteal

region.


18. All the injuries and, more particularly, the injury Nos. 3

and 4 do appear to be serious injuries which have been reflected

in medical Exbt.57 and the injuries were stated to be possible

with sharp edged weapon like articles 6, 17 and 19. Therefore,

there can be no dispute about the presence of Deepa on the scene.
In her evidence Deepa asserted that she also knew the accused in

the case and then points out that she heard the knocking of the

door at about 1.15.-1.30 a.m. She then saw the door being opened

by the father after putting on the electric light and the further

fact that as soon as the door was opened accused Manoj, DIlip and

Sunil and one unknown person entered the house and they were all

armed with knife. She asserted that accused Dilip (A-1) and Manoj

(A-3) started stabbing her father. She was terrified and,

therefore, shouted and her brother Prabhu also came and when he

intervened accused Dilip (A-1) and Manoj (A-3) stabbed him also on

his stomach and chest. She then claims that she tried to

intervene to save her brother. Accused Dilip told accused Sunil

and the unknown person to take Prabhu outside and accordingly

Sunil and the other unknown person took Prabhu outside. She then

claimed that Dilip and Manoj then rushed towards her. However,

Bijit came out and caught hold of Manoj and urged him not to

assault Deepa and, therefore, accused Manoj started inflicting

blows with knife on the stomach and chest of Bijit also. It is

further stated that Dilip and Manoj rushed towards her and

inflicted knife blows on face, stomach and other parts of her

body. She shouted and it is at that time her mother Indira came

and she was also given blows by Manoj and Dilip because of which

her mother fell down. She then adds that afterwards accused Sunil

entered the room and deceased Abhayraj also entered the room and

Sunil inflicted the blow with knife on him and he ran away and was

followed by Sunil. At that point of time, according to her, Manoj

dropped the knife in his hands and then accused Dilip and Manoj
left. She also asserted that she had told the names of Manoj,

Dilip and Sunil and one more unknown person when she telephoned

her uncle Balan (PW-1). According to her, she heard her brother

Prabhu who was lying outside the front door calling `mummy mummy'.

She, thereafter became unconscious and regained her consciousness

only on the next day in Bhagwati Hospital where she was admitted

for about 1-1/2 months. A statement came to be recorded only on

18.05.2004. In her examination-in-chief, she has asserted that

she knew Manoj and accused Sunil as Dilip's friends. She was

extensively cross-examined as regards the topography of the place

and the topography of her house as also the role played by him.


19. Before we consider her evidence, it must be noted that

though she did not know the father's name of accused Manoj Paswan

and further though she did not know about his job, business or

service she asserted that prior to the marriage of Prabhu with

Sushma, accused Manoj had interacted with her on many occasions.

She also asserted that Manoj lived in the house of accused Dilip

only. She also asserted that after the marriage between Prabhu

and Sushma, she had not gone to the house of Dilip. She also

denied the suggestion that Dilip had never come to their house

after the marriage of Sushma. She asserted that accused Dilip had

come to their house and given threats. In her cross-examination,

it has come that Abhayraj was her next door neighbour and used to

exchange the messages between Prabhu and Sushma. She has also

spoken about the efforts on the part of Dilip's sister Kalpana and

Dilip's mother to persuade Sushma to come back to her house even

after the marriage.
20. Significantly enough, in her lengthy cross-examination,

very little is asked to her about the actual incident of assault.

This witness was the most natural witness and had also the

opportunity to watch the dastardly attack and she had withstood

her cross-examination extremely well insofar as the attack by

accused Dilip and Manoj was concerned. She was not injured till

her father, deceased brother Prabhu and Bijit were attacked by the

accused persons. A wild suggestion was thrown to her about the

fact that she had not seen the incident as she was also being

assaulted with her mother, which Deepa has, of course, refuted.

Again a wild suggestion was thrown at her that the unknown person

had disconnected the electric supply and the telephone connection

and thereafter, the incident took place. Again one fantastic

suggestion was given to her that on the night of incident her

brother and Abhayraj had gone to Shivaji Nagar and consumed liquor

and they quarreled there and Abhayraj was killed at Shivaji Nagar

and thereafter those unknown persons chased her brother up to

their house. Some omissions were shown in her evidence and she

admitted that she had not stated that all the four persons were

armed with knife. She also accepted that she had not given the

description of knife since she was not asked. Insofar as the

cross-examination at the instance of accused No.2, Sunil is

concerned, one very significant fact has come in her evidence to

the effect that she asserted that she had told the names of Sunil

and Manoj as Dilip's friends. She had accepted that such fact was

not written in her statement. She had also stated before the

police that accused Sunil and the unknown person took Prabhu out
of the room and she did not know as to why this fact is not

written in her statement before police. She stated that it was

not true to say that she made a false statement that Sunil was

Dilip's friend. She further stated it was not true to say that

she made a false statement that her father opened the door and

accused Sunil and others entered the house armed with knives. She

also stated that it was not true to say that she made a false

statement that accused Sunil and one unknown person took Prabhu

out of the room as stated.


21. Inspite of all these omissions which have been proved, we

are convinced that Deepa had seen all the three accused persons.

Not only that, she had also identified all the three accused

persons. She had no reason not to identify Dilip and Manoj who

were staying almost in her neighbourhood. Her assertion that

Manoj was residing in Dilip's house has come in her cross-

examination and has not been explained anywhere. As far as

accused No. 2, Sunil is concerned, it must be noted that a poor

attempt was made that Yogita who was her friend had also a brother

called Sunil. Merely because the witness had not stated that

Sunil and Manoj were the friends of Dilip, it cannot be said that

Sunil was not identified. Her claim that she knew all the accused

persons could not be demolished in spite of the lengthy cross-

examination.


22. Shri Raj, learned counsel tried to submit that she had not

identified the accused persons individually in the Court. The

argument is clearly incorrect. If she had claimed that she had
known all the accused persons that could have been challenged in

the cross-examination by asking her to identify the accused

persons. The defence backtracked on that issue and did not choose

to ask her to identify the accused individually. It was obvious

that if she very well knew Dilip and Manoj, which claim cannot be

disputed, the remaining third accused would be Sunil and she would

be in a position to identify him individually and probably that is

why the defence did not take the chance. The other two accused

were also related to Dilip, being father and mother of Dilip.

Therefore, it was obvious that the witness had meant only accused

No. 2 as Sunil. The evidence of the witness about the role played

by Dilip and Manoj, to begin with, and thereafter by Sunil in

assaulting Abhayraj has gone almost unchallenged. There is

practically nothing in the cross-examination and the whole cross-

examination was only on fringes. She also went to the extent of

telling the colours of the clothes which were worn by Bijit and

her father as also described the clothes worn by Prabhu. That

claim has also not been disputed nor demolished in cross-

examination. Very strangely, the cross-examination was directed

at the omissions of the claims which the witness had not made in

her examination-in-chief and on the basis of the answers given in

cross-examination which was not permissible. The whole evidence

of the witness is extremely natural and the witness has not tried

to unnecessarily implicate anybody else. She has not assigned any

role to the unknown person. She has also not exaggerated by

stating that Sunil also assaulted herself, Indira or Bijit. It is

only as regards Abhayraj that she has attributed the assault to
Sunil against him. Her whole evidence being the evidence of

injured eye-witness was wholly credible as has been held by the

Trial Court as well as the High Court. Even her evidence, insofar

as the assault on herself and her father and Bijit is concerned,

is supported by the medical evidence which evidence we will

consider in the latter part of the judgment. We, therefore,

cannot accept the contention raised by Shri Agrawal that Manoj was

not identified merely because his name did not appear specifically

in the FIR. We also reject the contention of Shri Raj to the

effect that Sunil was not identified at all by this witness. This

takes us to the evidence of Indira, another witness injured during

the assault.


23. Indira also asserted in her evidence that she knew the

accused persons including Sunil (accused No.2) and accused Manoj

(accused No.3). She was woken up owing to the shrieks of Deepa

and Krishnan. She saw that Deepa and her husband were in the

injured condition when she entered the TV room. It is significant

that at that time, accused Dilip and accused Manoj rushed towards

her and inflicted blows with knife over her neck, chest, face and

hands. She has also seen accused Sunil (accused No.2) entering

the room at that time which version completely tallies with the

version of Deepa. She also attributed the neck injury of Abhayraj

to accused Sunil. It is significant that she has not referred to

deceased Prabhu who had been dragged outside. She then asserted

that accused Sunil chased Abhayraj who ran outside the house from

the back door. She asserted that Prabhu disclosed to her that

Dilip (accused No.1), Manoj (accused No.3) and Sunil (accused
No.2) and one more person had assaulted him with knife. She has

also extensively been cross-examined. In her cross-examination,

she had rightly asserted that when she entered the room, Prabhu

was not present in the room and Deepa had also fallen down. She

was asked about Deepa Kakad who resided adjacent to their house.

There is an important omission about Prabhu's having stated to her

that it was accused Dilip, Manoj and Sunil who had assaulted him.

In spite of that omission, it cannot be forgotten that Indira is

an injured eye-witness herself and had seen assault on deceased

Abhayraj by Sunil (accused No.2). She has also seen Dilip and

Manoj. Her claim in the examination-in-chief that she knew

accused Dilip (accused No.1), Manoj (accused No.3) and Sunil

(accused No.2) and further claim that Sunil and Manoj were friends

of Dilip has not been demolished at all in the cross-examination.

In fact there does not appear to be any challenge to that claim.

It must be noted that both Deepa (PW-4) and Indira (PW-8) have not

spoken about any dying declaration having been made by Prabhu to

PW-2, Shashidharan while they were being taken to the Hospital,

probably because both Deepa and this witness, Indira were

unconscious while Deepa regained her consciousness only in the

Hospital. This witness was very seriously injured and regained

her consciousness after quite some time. The only cross-

examination on behalf of accused No.2 was that there were a few

persons with the name Sunil in their locality. She also had not

stated that Sunil was a friend of Dilip. In our opinion, these

omissions do not help the defence as there was no reason for these

witnesses to falsely implicate Sunil. There is really no strained
relationship of this witness with Sunil at least shown in their

cross-examination. Under these circumstances, the witnesses would

gain nothing by falsely implicating Sunil and Manoj. There is

absolutely no cross-examination in respect of the identity.

Therefore, the evidence of these two witnesses was rightly

believed by the Trial Court as also by the High Court. In our

opinion, this clear cut eye-witness account by Deepa and Indira is

enough to convict Dilip (accused No.1), Manoj (accused No.3) and

accused Sunil (accused No.2).


24. During the arguments before us Shri Raj gave a notice under

Section 294 (2), Cr.P.C. to the State counsel to admit the

document which is so-called dying declaration of Prabhu dated

17.05.2004. This dying declaration was a part of the charge-sheet

and the copy thereof was supplied to the accused persons. Very

strangely, this dying declaration was not brought forth on record

by the prosecution. The said dying declaration now having been

admitted by the Public Prosecutor can be read in evidence. It is

counter signed by Dr. S.S. Anakal (PW-5). It is also counter

signed by the Investigating Officer Kailash Bharve. It bears a

thumb mark. This was made by deceased Prabhu wherein it has been

stated that at about 1.30 a.m. Prabhu's father was assaulted by 2-

3 persons with knife and when he came out, he was also assaulted.

At that time accused Dilip and accused Manoj inflicted knife blows

on him and at that time two more persons entered the house and

started assaulting them. Further it is stated that while Dilip

and Manoj were trying to assault his mother, he tried to stop

them. He has also suggested that since he had married Dilip's
sister Sushma, Dilip, Manoj and their other associates had entered

their house and assaulted them. In fact when the matter was

pending before the High Court for confirmation, the accused filed

an application under Section 391 of the Code of Criminal Procedure

to take on record this dying declaration. We have seen that

application. In that application production of additional

evidence under Section 391, Cr.P.C. was suggested on the ground

that though such a dying declaration was given to Dr. S.S. Anakal

by deceased Prabhu, the same was not brought on record by the

prosecution and the same was suppressed from the defence before

the Trial Court. It was stated to be a vital omission on the part

of the prosecution and it was further claimed that it went to the

root of the matter as far as the culpability of accused Sunil is

concerned. It was also pointed out that in the said dying

declaration, the name of Sunil Yadav was not mentioned and that

due to inadvertence, the said dying declaration was not confronted

during the evidence of PW-5, Dr.S.S.Anakal. The application was

rejected by the High Court. Very strangely, this application was

opposed by the Public Prosecutor as also the learned counsel

appearing for Dilip (accused No.1) and Manoj (accused No.3). The

High Court observed in its order dated 01.09.2007 that though Dr.

Anakal was examined as witness and though the copy of this dying

declaration was furnished to all the accused persons during the

trial, no question was put with regard to Prabhu's dying

declaration by the counsel for accused No.2, Sunil before the

Trial Court. It was on these grounds that the High Court observed

that in view of the strong opposition by Dilip (accused No.1) and
Manoj (accused No.3) to the application, the High Court was not

inclined to exercise its discretion in favour of the appellant and

on that ground the application stood rejected.


25. To say the least, we are surprised by the order passed by

the High Court. In fact the proceedings before the High Court

were in the nature of an extended trial. The confirmational

proceedings are always the original proceedings. The High Court

was dealing with the accused who was facing death sentence.

Therefore, merely because no question was asked to Dr. S.S. Anakal

(PW-5), the document could not have been held back and an

opportunity was bound to be given by getting the document proved

if necessary by re-calling Dr. Anakal by the High Court itself.

The task of the Public Prosecutor is not only to secure the

conviction, he has a duty to the Court. He is an officer of the

Court and, therefore, in all fairness, firstly the document should

have been brought on record and secondly, even if Dr. Anakal who

recorded the dying declaration was not confronted with that dying

declaration, that opportunity could not have been denied before

the High Court since the proceedings before the High Court were in

the nature of original proceedings and an extended trial. We are

surprised that the Public Prosecutor opposed the application.

Fairness of the trial is the basic requirement in the criminal

law. We think that the Public Prosecutor ought not to have

opposed the production of the document. We, therefore, allowed

the production of the document.


26. In a reported judgment Rampal Pithwa Rahidas & Others. v.
State of Maharashtra [1994 Supp (2) SCC 73] somewhat similar

situation occurred where this Court reiterated the duty of the

investigating agency to act honestly and fairly. In that case a

communication-cum-application by an approver, before he was made

approver wherein he had claimed the bail on the ground that he

knew nothing about the offence and he was unnecessarily being

incarcerated, was not confronted to him at the time of trial. The

Court took the view that though the witness was not confronted

with that statement and in a strict sense it was not brought

before the Court, yet the same communication could be looked into

by the Courts. The Court also observed in paragraph 37 as under:


"The quality of a nation's civilization," it is said,
"can be largely measured by the methods it uses in the
enforcement of criminal law" and going by the manner in which
the investigating agency acted in this case causes concern to
us. In every civilized society the police force is invested
with the powers of investigation of the crime to secure
punishment for the criminal and it is in the interest of the
society that the investigating agency must act honestly and
fairly and not resort to fabricating false evidence or
creating false clues only with a view to secure conviction
because such acts shake the confidence of the common man not
only in the investigating agency but in the ultimate analysis
in the system of dispensation of criminal justice. Let no
guilty man go unpunished but let the end not justify the
means! The Courts must remain ever alive to this truism.
Proper results must be obtained by recourse to proper means -
otherwise it would be an invitation to anarchy."



27. Shri Raj urged that we should send back the matter for

further examination of Dr. S.S. Anakal and, if necessary, the

other witnesses like the Investigating Officer who has also

counter singed the said dying declaration. Shri Gaurav Agrawal

also urged that in case the dying declaration is sent back then

further opportunity will have to be given even to accused Nos. 1
and 3 to further cross-examine the witnesses as the dying

declaration clearly goes against at least accused Nos. 1 and 3.


28. Ordinarily, we would have sent back the matter. However,

we cannot ignore the fact that all the three accused persons are

facing death sentence awarded by the Trial Court and confirmed by

the High Court. We would not, therefore, increase the agonies of

the accused persons by sending back the matter to the High Court;

in stead, since accused No.1 and 3 did not have opportunity to

cross-examine the witnesses about the document, we will not

consider the documents against accused Nos. 1 and 3. Insofar as

accused No.2, Sunil is concerned, it is true that his name does

not appear in the said dying declaration but in our considered

opinion that would be of no consequence for the simple reason that

the evidence of the eye-witness completely fixes the criminal

liability on the part of accused No.2, Sunil. Therefore, even if

the said dying declaration is somewhat helpful to Sunil, that by

itself will not wipe out the evidence of the two eye-witnesses

whose evidence was credible as held by the Trial Court as well as

the Appellate Court.


29. Thus in our view, the conviction of all the three

appellants before us as ordered by the Sessions Judge and

confirmed by the High court is correct and we confirm the same.


30. This, however, takes us to the question of sentence. This

is a case where the death sentence has been ordered by the

Sessions Judge which has been confirmed by the High Court. We

must, at this juncture, take the overall circumstances while
taking into consideration the death sentence awarded by the Courts

below. As held in Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab [1983 (3) SCC

470] as also in Bachchan Singh v. State of Punjab [1980 (2) SCC

684], we must weigh the circumstances justifying the grant of

death sentence vis-`-vis the mitigating circumstances. The High

Court considered the following circumstances justifying the

imposition of death penalty"


"(a) Helpless victims

(b) Unarmed victims

(c) Victims woken from sleep at midnight

(d) Manner of inflicting injuries, 20-30 serious injuries on
death of the deceased, whereas even a single injury would
have been sufficient to kill, shows the barbarous attitude;

(e) Attacking ruthlessly six persons, Deepa and Indira were
let off presumed to be dead, seeking to wipe off the entire
family;

(f) Attack on every vital organ;

(g) Young boy Bijit was brutally assaulted;

(h) Not only Prabhu, even the messenger boy Abhayraj was
brutally assaulted;

(i) The time chosen was past midnite hence clearly
premeditated;

(j) Assault on lower caste based on caste hatred:

(k) Marriage took place on 29.10.2003 and the assault was on
17.05.2004 i.e. after a lapse of seven months. As Dilip was
totally opposed to the marriage, the above attack was highly
premeditated and not at the heat of moment.



31. The High Court relied on the judgment of Dhananjoy

Chatterjee @ Dhana v. State of West Bengal [2004 (9) SCC 751] and

quoted extensively therefrom. One other case Ronny alias Ronald

James Alwaris & Ors. v. State of Maharashtra [1998 (3) SCC 625]
was also relied on by the High Court. The High Court extensively

quoted from the judgment in Ediga Anamma v. State of Andhra

Pradesh [1974 (4 )SCC 443] and State of U.P. v. Dharmendra Singh &

Anr. [1999 (8) SCC 325] as also Lehna v. State of Haryana [2002

(3) SCC 76].


32. However, even a close scrutiny of the judgment does not

show any effort on the part of the High Court to consider the

mitigating circumstances, though such exercise has been done by

the Trial Court in paragraph 42 of its judgment. The mitigating

circumstances considered by the Sessions Court are:


"1) The age of the accused persons being between 20-25 years;
2) Their clean past, in the sense they were not involved in any
offence previously"




33. Shri Raj and Shri Gaurav Agrawal addressed us extensively

on the mitigating circumstances. As far as accused No.1, Dilip

and accused No.3 Manoj are concerned, the learned counsel first

pointed out that apart from the two circumstances considered by

the Sessions Judge, namely, the young age of the accused persons

and there being no criminal antecedents, there were number of

other mitigating circumstances which the Courts below had not

considered. It was submitted that accused No.1, Dilip must have

felt morally justified in attacking the family members due to the

fact that his younger sister had revolted against the family and

got married to Prabhu, a Keralite. Therefore, to preserve the

family honour, Dilip had taken the revenge of the so-called insult

of his family. It was also pointed out that since Manoj was the
resident of the same house, he also may have been persuaded to

join the crime as also Sunil who was all through described as the

friend of Dilip.


34. Learned counsel further argues that insofar as Manoj was

concerned, he apparently had no enmity though he might have felt

it necessary to display the loyalty to the family in whose house

he was living and it could have been only out of that, that the

murders took place. Learned counsel further argued that the

deaths of Bijit and Abhayraj were in reality not the intended

deaths but they became the victims of the circumstances since

Bijit tried to stop the assailants. He was not supposed to be

present there but his fate drew him in the house and he became the

prey of the murderous assault. Perhaps nothing would have

happened had he not come to the room. He not only came in the

room but also tried the stop the assailants from assaulting.


35. As regards Abhayraj, learned counsel pointed out that he

was not there in the beginning but he being the immediate

neighbour must have come attracted by the shrieks and lost his

life. According to the learned counsel, there is very little or

almost no evidence available as to how Abhayraj was killed and by

whom. The counsel pointed out that the only allegation was that

Sunil (A-2) dealt a blow on his neck and when he ran away he was

followed by Sunil and the unknown person. Learned counsel also

highlighted that the possibility of the said unknown person being

responsible for the death of Abhayraj and Prabhu could not be

ruled out since, as per the evidence of Deepa, Sunil and that
unknown person took Prabhu out and then it is not established as

to how many blows were dealt on Prabhu and, therefore, Sunil alone

could not be held to be responsible. There may be a substantive

contribution on the part of that unknown person to the crime, at

least for the murder of Prabhu and Abhayraj. Learned counsel

further highlighted the role of the unknown person and the fact

that the said unknown person remained a mysterious part of the

investigation and trial. Therefore, it was ultimately urged that

it could not be deemed to be an assault with a common intention to

wipe out the whole family as has been tried to be suggested by the

prosecution.


36. Learned counsel further submitted that it could not be said

that the accused could not be reformed, particularly, because

their antecedents were clean or at least the prosecution was

unable to point out any criminal activity in the past on the part

of the accused persons.


37. Shri Raj, appearing for accused No.2, Sunil also supported

these arguments and added that, in reality, Sunil could not be

attributed with the brutal attack. Undoubtedly, Sunil did not

assault either Krishnan Nochil or Prabhu, to begin with, he was

merely attributed assault on Prabhu after Prabhu was dragged out

for which there was no evidence as to whether it was he or other

unknown person who had given blows to him. As far as the

allegation regarding Abhayraj is concerned, learned counsel

pointed out that like Prabhu, there was no evidence available as

to how many blows had been given on Abhayraj's body and by whom.
Learned counsel pointed out that it was only one blow which was

given to Abhayraj. Learned counsel also urged that it must have

been because of the friendship between the other accused and Sunil

that Sunil had accompanied the accused persons but it could not be

said that Sunil also shared the common intention to wipe out the

whole family. In fact, Sunil did not act, to begin with, insofar

as the assaults on Krishnan and Prabhu were concerned. It was

further pointed out that Sunil was merely 19 years of age at the

time of incident.


38. The Trial Court has made some exercise in weighing the

mitigating circumstances though such conscious effort does not

seem to have been made by the High Court. In terms of the law

laid down in Bachan Singh's case (cited supra) as also in Machhi

Singh's case (cited supra) and number of subsequent decisions of

this Court thereafter, it would be now our task to weigh those

circumstances.


39. All murders are foul, however, the degree of brutality,

depravity and diabolic nature, differ in each case. It has been

held in the earlier decisions of this Court which we may not

repeat that the circumstance under which the murders took place,

differ from case to case and there cannot be a straightjacket

formula for deciding upon the circumstances under which the death

penalty is a must.


40. Insofar as the accused No. 1, Dilip is concerned, there can

be no doubt that he was the chief architect of the crime. There

can also be no doubt that he entered the house of the victims in
the dead of night. Obviously, the visit was not intended to be a

courtesy call. It was obvious that he had visited being duly

armed and in company of three other friends. What was then the

psychology of Dilip, accused No.1 and why did he wait for seven

months are the relevant questions which must attract our

attention.


41. Sushma was the younger sister of this accused. It is a

common experience that when the younger sister commits something

unusual and in this case it was an intercaste, intercommunity

marriage out of the secret love affair, then in the society it is

the elder brother who justifiably or otherwise is held responsible

for not stopping such affair. It is held as the family defeat.

At times, he has to suffer taunts and snide remarks even from the

persons who really have no business to poke their nose into the

affairs of the family. Dilip, therefore, must have been a prey of

the so-called insult which his younger sister had imposed upon his

family and that must have been in his mind for seven long months.

It has come in the evidence that even if the marriage was

performed with Prabhu, there were efforts made by the family

members of Dilip to bring Sushma back. It has come in evidence

that mother of Dilip tried to lure back Sushma and so did her

other married sister Kalpana who actually went on to meet Sushma

in her college. Those efforts paid no dividends. In stead,

Sushma kept on attending the college thereby openly mixing with

the society. This must have added insult to the injury felt by

the family members and more particularly, accused Dilip. Why did

he wait for seven months? The answer lies in the fact that Sushma
became pregnant and thus reached a point of no return. Till such

time as she became pregnant, there might have been some hopes in

the family to win her back but once she became pregnant, even that

distant hope faded away and, in our opinion, that is the reason

why this ghastly episode took place. As if all this was not

sufficient, Dilip himself must have had the feeling of being

cheated. It is not that Dilip did not know Prabhu who was living

only three houses away from his house. The secret love affair

which went on between Sushma and Prabhu for which Abhayraj acted

as a messenger must have raised the feeling of being cheated by

Prabhu. This was further aggravated because of the so-called

higher status of a Brahmin family on the part of Dilip and so-

called non-Brahmin status of Prabhu. It has come on record that

Sushma was moved to Andheri at the house of Shashidharan and this

ought to have added as a spark which resulted in tornado. Dilip

undoubtedly was a young person not even having crossed his 25

years of life and not having any criminal antecedent. If he

became the victim of his wrong but genuine caste considerations,

it would not justify the death sentence. The murders were the

outcome of social issue like a marriage with a person of so-called

lower caste. However, a time has come when we have to consider

these social issues as relevant, while considering the death

sentence in the circumstances as these. The caste is a concept

which grips a person before his birth and does not leave him even

after his death. The vicious grip of the caste, community,

religion, though totally unjustified, is a stark reality. The

psyche of the offender in the background of a social issue like an
inter-caste-community marriage, though wholly unjustified would

have to be considered in the peculiar circumstances of this case.


42. No doubt, the murder was brutal. However, it has been

pointed out by Shri Gaurav Agrawal as also Shri Raj that this was

not a diabolic murder nor had the murderers acted in depravity of

their minds by disfiguring the bodies. The incident must have

taken place barely within 10-15 minutes when they came, assaulted

the family members and left. True it is that the two ladies who

were assaulted were helpless and so were Krishnan and Prabhu. But

when we weigh all the circumstances, particularly, about the

mindset of Dilip, the cruel acts on the part of the accused would

not justify the death sentence. The disturbed mental feeling or

the constant feeling of injustice has been considered by this

Court as a mitigating circumstance in Om Prakash v. State of

Haryana [1999 (3) SCC 19] where the accused had committed the

murder of seven persons. That is also an indicator to the fact

that mere number of persons killed is not by itself a circumstance

justifying the death sentence. In fact in one other case reported

as Ram Pal v. State of U.P. [2003 (7) SCC 141] total 21 persons

were killed as the accused trapped them in a house and burnt the

house. Shri Karanjkar, appearing on behalf of the State very

strongly contended as against this, that in the present case while

four persons were killed, two helpless ladies were also assaulted

and very seriously injured and it is only because the accused

thought that those two ladies had died and left, that the lives of

Deepa and Indira were spared. Therefore, in the circumstances of

this case, we must lean in favour of the death sentence. In a
death sentence matter, it is not only the nature of the crime but

the background of the criminal, his psychology, his social

conditions and his mindset for committing the offence are also

relevant. No doubt in Ravji alias Ram Chandra v. State of

Rajasthan [1996 (2) SCC 175], this Court held as under:


"...The crimes had been committed with utmost cruelty and
brutality without any provocation, in a calculated manner. It is
the nature and gravity of the crime but not the criminal, which
are germane for consideration of appropriate punishment in a
criminal trial. The Court will be failing in its duty if
appropriate punishment is not awarded for a crime which has been
committed not only against the individual victim but also against
the society to which the criminal and victim belong. The
punishment to be awarded for a crime must not be irrelevant but it
should conform to and be consistent with the atrocity and
brutality with which the crime has been perpetrated, the enormity
of the crime warranting public abhorrence and it should "respond
to the society's cry for justice against the criminal"...."



43. It is also true that this case was followed in as many as

six cases where the death sentence was approved of. However, in

his judgment reported as Santosh Kumar Satishbhushan Bariyar v.

State of Maharashtra [JT 2009 (7) SC 248] Hon. Sinha, J. pointed

out that this judgment is per incuriam as the law laid down

therein is contrary to the law laid down in Bachan Singh's case

(cited supra) where the principle has fallen out to the effect

that the Court should not confine its consideration principally or

merely to the circumstances connected with the particular crime

but also give due consideration to the circumstances of the

criminal. It is because of this that we have ventured to consider

the mindset of accused No.1, Dilip and the vicious caste grip that

might have catapulted the crime committed by him. We would, thus,

follow Bachan Singh's case (cited supra) and the principles
therein rather than following the narrow approach given in Ravji's

case (cited supra).


44. Once we decide not to award the death sentence to accused

No.1, Dilip, the accused No.3, Manoj also deserves not to be given

death sentence. Even he is a person without any criminal

antecedents and he appears to have joined the company of Dilip

only out of his commitment as he was shown to be a resident of the

same house. We, therefore, do not think that even he deserves

death penalty. Accused No.2, Sunil has comparatively a lesser

role. Admittedly, he has not assaulted Krishnan or Prabhu, to

begin with. Who has assaulted Prabhu and Abhayraj is still not

clear, as it could also be that in the assaults the leading role

could have been taken by the unknown accused. In that view, he

also does not deserve the death sentence. The question is then

how are these accused persons to be dealt with. Ordinarily, they

would be liable to be awarded the life imprisonment.


45. However, in the peculiar circumstances of this case, mere

life imprisonment which is capable of resulting into 20 years of

imprisonment or 14 years of actual imprisonment may not be

adequate punishment for these accused persons. Considering the

overall circumstances, we feel that accused No.1, Dilip and

accused No.3, Manoj who assaulted Krishnan, Prabhu and the two

helpless ladies would deserve the life imprisonment. But we

direct that they shall not be released unless they complete 25

years of actual imprisonment. In case of Sunil, however, since he

had not assaulted the helpless ladies nor had he taken part in the
assault on Krishnan, he deserves the life imprisonment in the

ordinary sense. He shall have to undergo the 20 years of actual

punishment. Such a course has been held to be permissible in Haru

Ghosh v. State of West Bengal [JT 2009 (11) SC 240] pronounced by

this Bench, authored by V.S.Sirpurkar, J. This view was taken on

the basis of the law laid down in Swami Shradhanand @ Murali

Manohar Mishra v. State of Karnataka [JT 2008 (8) SC 27] where

this Court after considering several cases held that such a course

was permissible. We accordingly dismiss these appeals, however,

modifying the sentences as shown above. The appeals are disposed

off accordingly.




.............................J.
[V.S. SIRPURKAR]



........................
.....J.
[DEEPAK VERMA]
NEW DELHI
December 10, 2009.

Thursday, February 4, 2010

വോട്ടര്‍പട്ടികയും പര്‍ദയും - തമിഴ്നാട് ഹൈക്കോടതി വിധി

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

Dated: 07.09.2006

Coram:

The Honourable Mr.A.P.SHAH, CHIEF JUSTICE
and
The Honourable Mr.Justice K.CHANDRU

Writ Petition No. 26841 of 2006

M.Ajmal Khan ... Petitioner

vs.

1. The Election Commission of India
rep. by its Chief Election Commissioner,
New Delhi-1.

2. Union of India
rep. by its Secretary to Government,
Public (Elections) Department,
New Delhi -1.

3. State of Tamil Nadu,
rep. by its Chief Secretary to Government,
Fort.St.George, Chennai-9.

4. The State Election Commissioner,
Chennai.

5. The District Collector,
Madurai District, Madurai. ... Respondents

Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying to issue a writ of mandamus forbearing the respondents from publishing or releasing the Electoral Rolls with the photographs of eligible women voters particularly Muslim Gosha Women voters of all the Constituencies in the State of Tamil Nadu, especially for the ensuring bye-election to Madurai Central Assembly Constitutency.

For Petitioner ::: Mr.K.M.Vijayan,
Senior Counsel
for Mr.K.Premkumar

For Respondents
1 & 2 ::: Mr.G.Rajagopalan,
Senior Counsel

For Respondents
3 to 5 ::: Mr.Raja Kalifulla
Government Pleader

O R D E R

(The Order of the Court was made by Hon'ble The Chief Justice)

The Election Commission of India with a view to improving the fidelity of the electoral rolls and to evolve methods to check impersonation and eradicate bogus voting decided to undertake the project of putting the photographs in the electoral roll itself so as to achieve the purpose of proper identification of the electors at the polling stations. Accordingly, the Commission during the year 2003 undertook pilot projects in two Assembly Constituencies in Kerala and two Assembly Constituencies in Harayana. In view of the encouraging results, the Commission issued a direction vide its communication dated 18.12.2003 to the Chief Electoral Officers of all the States and Union Territories. Pursuant to the directions issued from time to time in this regard the work had begun in various States for preparing electoral rolls with photographs. So far as the State of Kerala and the Union Territory of Pondicherry are concerned, the preparation of electoral rolls with photographs has been fully completed and also used in the General Elections held in May 2006. In so far as the State of West Bengal is concerned, in 46 Assembly Constituencies the work was completed and the photo rolls were used in the General Elections held in May 2006. In so far as the State of Tamil Nadu is concerned, the Election Commission has directed to prepare and revise the electoral rolls with photographs of voters keeping 1.1.2006 as qualifying date for Madurai Central Assembly Constituency and in respect of the other 233 Assembly Constituencies, the qualifying date is 1.1.2007. Bye-election has to be conducted before 19.11.2006 for Madurai Central Assembly Constituency in view of the sudden demise of its representative immediately after the General Elections in May 2006. In respect of 143- Madurai Assembly Constituency photo electoral roll has been prepared and the draft photo electoral roll was published on 11.8.2006 and the final photo electoral roll is ready to be published.

2. The constitutional validity of the aforesaid direction is put in issue in this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The petitioner-M.Ajmal Khan is seeking for issuance of writ of mandamus forbearing the Election Commission from in any way publishing or releasing the photographs of the women particularly the Muslim Gosha women in the eligible voter's list in respect of all the Constituencies in the State of Tamil Nadu particularly for the
ensuring bye-election to Madurai Central Assembly Constituency. The contention of the petitioner is that though the requirement of photo identity cards to be kept by eligible voters for the purpose of voting cannot be disputed or the same cannot be found illegal as it is in the welfare of the General Election and towards the fairness, but the usage of such photographs in the final electoral rolls, which is easily accessible to any one including the representatives of political parties on payment of necessary charges, cannot be said to be necessary and mandatory for ensuring fair election. The usage of photographs in the electoral rolls of eligible voters and in particular the photographs of Muslim Gosha Women will easily find its way into the hands of those persons whose identity is not known, which is opposed to religious beliefs, tenets of Koran and it will cause irreparable loss, damage, mental agony to the entire muslim community at large. It is contended that wearing of purdah by Muslim women is one of the principles laid down in Holy Koran and it has to be strictly followed by Muslim women. From the time immemorial the Muslim women are adhering to these principles in their life. Therefore, any interference with such religious practice would amount to interfering with the fundamental right of the Muslim women, which is guaranteed under Article 25 of the Constitution of India.

3. Mr.K.M.Vijayan, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner strenuously contended that wearing of purdah by Muslim women forms integral part of the religion and cannot be disassociated from that. That being so, the impugned direction of the Election Commission amounts to violation of Article 25(1) of the Constitution of India. Learned counsel cited several verses from Koran from the translation of M.M.Pickthali which according to learned counsel show that there are injunctions in Koran which prohibit ladies coming out in public showing their faces and a fortiori taking of photograph. In any event, according to Mr.K.M.Vijayan, the right protected by Article 25 of the Constitution can be taken away only by a valid law enacted by the State Legislature or the Union Legislature and not by a direction of the Election Commission which is in the nature of an executive direction under Article 324 of the Constitution of India. Learned senior counsel urged that the impugned direction is also violative of right of privacy protected by Article 21 of the Constitution of India. A contention is also raised by the learned senior counsel that the impugned direction is contrary to the Registration of Electors Rules, 1760.

4. In reply, Mr.G.Rajagopalan, learned senior counsel appearing for the Election Commission submitted that the Election Commission with a view to ensure free and fair poll is empowered to issue necessary directions under Article 324 of the Constitution of India for preparation of photo electoral rolls. He submitted that Rule 4 of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 clearly provides that the roll for each constituency shall be prepared in such form and in such language or languages as the Election Commission may direct. The Election Commission has already issued necessary directions under Rule 4 and issued the form for preparation of photo electoral rolls. He submitted that the contention of the petitioner that the usage of photographs in the electoral rolls of the eligible voters and particularly the Muslim Gosha women is opposed to their religious belief has no legal basis whatsoever. In fact there has been no problem in Kerala, Pondicherry and West Bengal and all Muslim women cooperated. Even with regard to Madurai Central Assembly Constituency there was no complaint at all from any Muslim women when they were photographed. He submitted that any right of a citizen with regard to the election is pure, simple and statutory right and the Commission, as a constitutional authority, is bound to treat all equally and no exception could be taken on the supposed ground of any religion.

5. The main submission of Mr.K.M.Vijayan is that Gosha or Purdah forms integral part of the religion and therefore, Election Commission has no right to issue any direction interfering with such right protected by Article 25 of the Constitution. The relevant part of Article 25 reads as under: -

" 25. Freedom of conscience and free profession, practice and propagation of religion: -- (1) Subject to public order, morality and health and to the other provisions of this Part, all persons are equally entitled to freedom of conscience and the right freely to profess, practise and propagate religion.

(2) Nothing in this article shall affect the operation of any existing law or prevent the State from making any law--

(a) regulating or restricting any economic, financial, political or other secular activity which may be associated with religious practice;

(b) providing for social welfare and reform or the throwing open of Hindu religious institutions of a public character to all classes and sections of Hindus."
A bare reading of this article shows that the freedom is subject to public order, morality and health. So the article itself permits a legislation in the interest of public order, morality, health, etc.

6. The meaning of religion the term as employed in Article 25 and the nature of protection conferred by Article 25 stands explained in The State of Bombay v. Narasu Appa, AIR 1952 Bombay 84, where Chagla, C.J. Speaking for the Bench in dealing with the validity of Bombay Prevention of Hindu Bigamous Marriages Act, whether was in violation of Article 25 of the Constitution, held as follows: -

" A sharp distinction must be drawn between religious faith and belief and religious practices. What the State protects is religious faith and belief. If religious practices run counter to public order, morality or health or a policy of social welfare upon which the State has embarked, then the religious practices must give way before the good of the people of the State as a whole. It is rather difficult to accept the proposition that polygamy is an integral part of Hindu religion. But even assuming that polygamy is a recognized institution according to Hindu religious practice, the right of the State to legislate on questions relating to marriage cannot be disputed. Marriage is undoubtedly a social institution, an institution in which the State is vitally interested. If, therefore, the State of Bombay compels Hindus to become monogamists, it is a measure of social reform, and the State is empowered to legislate with regard to social reform under Art.25(2)(b) notwithstanding the fact that it may interfere with the right of a citizen freely to profess, practise and propagate religion. Therefore, this legislation does not contravene Art.25(1) of the Constitution."

7. In Masud Alam v. Commissioner of Police, AIR 1956 Cal.9, the Commissioner of Police refused his permission to the use of an electrical loudspeaker five times a day for calling the Azan (call for prayer) as several residents of the locality complained against the practice. It was argued for the Mutawalli of the mosque that had introduced the loudspeaker that the liberty allowed under Art.25 of the Constitution has been curtailed by the suppression of the use of loudspeakers to propagate the Azan in a very crowded and noisy locality where the Azan cannot be heard, unless magnified by some such device as a loudspeaker. Sinha,J. rejecting the argument observed thus: -

" No doubt, India is a secular State and under Art.25 of the Constitution, all persons are at liberty to freely practise their religion. But the above argument overlooks the essential features of Art.25. For, a sharp distinction must be drawn between religious faith and belief and religious practices. What the State protects is religious faith and belief. If religious practices run counter to public order, morality or health, then the religious practices must give way before the good of the people of the State as a whole."
The learned Judge further observed,

"I have a few words to say about the use of loudspeakers in connection with religious houses or festivals. The discovery of the means to magnify sound has indeed been a major scientific discovery of the age and is utilised in many useful ways, e.g., the telephone, radio etc. But like every modern discovery in science, it has helped to create not merely a heaven but also a hell.

The indiscriminate use of the electric loudspeaker in connection with religious festivals in the city is a standing grievance of every peace-loving citizen. The most offending instances are the uses of which it is put in connection with Hindu festivals, when the city is rocked with the raucous cacophony of a thousand loudspeakers, dolling out cheap jazz or cinema music, which is not only singularly inappropriate to such occasions, but to my mind, destructive of public health and morals."

8. In Gulam Abbas v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (1984) 1 SCC 81, the Supreme Court taking note of the fact that for several years there had been violent clashes between the Shias and Sunnis of Mohalla Doshipura, Varanasi leading to proceedings and several petitions before the Supreme Court and to find a perennial solution to the problem appointed a Committee of 7 persons constituting of 3 nominees of Shias and 3 nominees of Sunnis and the Divisional Commissioner as the Chairman. The Chairman despite the opposition of Sunnis, recommended that shifting of their two graves so as to separate the places of worship of Shias and Sunnis was feasible. The Sunnis challenge implementation of the recommendation on the ground of violation of their rights under Arts.25 and 26 and lack of jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to so order. The Supreme Court held:

"The exercise of fundamental rights under Arts.25 and 26 is not absolute but must yield to give way to maintenance of public order and the impugned suggestion was mooted by the Court and has now been found to be feasible by the Chairman of the Committee in the larger interest of the society for the purpose of maintaining public order on every occasion of the performance of religious ceremonies and function by members of both the sects. If the Court finds the implementation of the suggestion to be eminently fit in the interest to maintenance of public order consent of either party would be immaterial."

9. In M.Ismail Faruqui (Dr.) v. Union of India, (1994) 6 SCC 360 the Constitution Bench held that the protection under Articles 25 and 26 of the Constitution is with respect to religious practice which forms an essential and integral part of the religion. A practice may be a religious practice but not an essential and integral part of practice of that religion. The latter is not protected by Article 25.

10. In Mohd. Hanif Quareshi v. State of Bihar, AIR 1958 SC 731, the State legislation placing a total ban on cow slaughter was under challenge. One of the submissions made was that such a ban offended Article 25 of the Constitution because such ban came in the way of the sacrifice of a cow on a particular day where it was considered to be religious by Muslims. Having made a review of various religious books, the Court concluded that it did not appear to be obligatory that a person must sacrifice a cow. It was optional for a Muslim to do so. The fact of an option seems to run counter to the notion of an obligatory duty. Many Muslims do not sacrifice a cow on the Id day. As it was not proved that the sacrifice of a cow on a particular day was an obligatory overt act for a Mussalman for the performance of his religious beliefs and ideas, it could not be held that a total ban on the slaughter of cows ran counter to Article 25 of the Constitution. This judgment has been upheld by the Bench of seven Judges in State of Gujarat v. Mirzapur Moti Kureshi Kassab Jamat, (2005) 8 SCC 534.

11. In the light of the decisions enunciated in the aforesaid judgment, it is necessary to examine whether the Gosha or Purdah is an essential ingredient or part of the Muslim religion. The famed Koran translator Mohammad Marmaduke Pickthall, whose official translation of Koran was cited before us said in his 1925 lecture "The Relation of the Sexes" that there is no text in the Koran, no saying of our Prophet, which can possibly be held to justify the practice of depriving women of the natural benefits which Allah has decreed for all mankind (i.e. Sunshine and fresh air and healthy movement).... The true Islamic tradition enjoins the veiling of the hair and neck, and modest conduct that is all. This is borne out by the following Hadith: Ayesha (R) reported that Asmaa the daughter of Abu Bakr (R) came to the messenger of Allah (S) while wearing thin clothing. He approached her and said : 'O Asmaa! When a girl reaches the menstrual age, it is not proper that anything should remain exposed except this and this. He pointed to the face and hands." (Abu Dawood). He further observed that veiling of the face by women was not originally an Islamic customs. It was prevalent in many cities of the East before the coming of Islam, but not in the cities of Arabia. The purdah system, as it now exists in India, was quite undreamt of by the Muslims in the early centuries, who had adopted the face-veil and some other fashions for their women when they entered the cities of Syria, Mesopotamia, Persia and Egypt. It was once a concession to the prevailing custom and was a protection to their women from misunderstanding by peoples accustomed to associate unveiled faces with loose character. Later on it was adopted even in the cities of Arabia as a mark of (tamaddun) a word generally translated as 'civilization' but which in Arabic still retains a stronger flavour of its root meaning 'townsmanship' that is carried by the English word. It has never been a universal custom for Muslim women, the great majority of whom have never used it, since the majority of the Muslim women in the world are peasants who work with their husbands and brothers in the fields. For them the face-veil would be an absurd encumbrance. Thus the Purdah system is neither of Islamic nor Arabian origin. It is of Zoroastrian Persian, and Christian Byzantine origin. It has nothing to do with the religion of Islam, and, for practical reasons, it has never been adopted by the great majority of Muslim women.... The Purdah system is not a part of the Islamic law. It is a custom of that Court introduced after the Khilafat had degenerated from the true Islamic standard and, under Persian and Byzantine influences, had become mere Oriental despotism. It comes from the source of weakness to Islam not from the source of strength.

12. A noted Sudanese scholar, Dr.Hassan al-Turabi, in his trace "On the Position of Women in Islam and in Islamic Society" states that the verses of the Koran ordained that the wives of the Propet (peace upon him) draw a curtain (to ensure privacy in the Prophet's room which naturally attracted many visitors of all sorts), and that they dress up completely without showing any part of their bodies including face and hands to any man; though all other Muslim women were exempted from these restrictions.

13. The Canadian writers Syed Mumtaz Ali and Rabia Mills in their essay Social Degradation of Women a Crime and a Libel on Islam explain:

" One must realize and appreciate the fact that the commandment in the Qur'an in Chapter 33, verse 53, with respect to the Hijab, applies only to the "Mothers of the believers" (the wives of the Holy Prophet, p.b.u.h.) whereas the wording of the Qur'an in Chapter 33 verse 55, applies to all Muslim women in general. No screen or Hijab (Purdah) is mentioned in this verse it prescribes only a veil to cover the bosom and modesty in dress. Hence the unlawfulness of the practice of the Indian-style system of Purdah (full face veiling). Under this system, the Hijab is not only imposed upon all Muslim women, but it is also quite often forced upon them in an obligatory and mandatory fashion. Even the literal reading/translation of this Quranic verse does not support the assertion that the Hijab is recommended for all Muslim women. The Hijab/screen was a special feature of honour for the Prophet's p.b.u.h. wives and it was introduced only about five or six years before his death."

14. In the English translation of Koran by Muhammad Asad in Note 37 states "We may safely assume that the meaning of illa ma zahara minha is much wider, and that the deliberate vagueness of this phrase is meant to allow for all the time-bound changes that are necessary for man's moral and social growth.". In the Article "The Question of Hijab: Suppression or Liberation" published by The Institute of Islamic Information and Education (III&E) and reproduced in electronic form by Islamic Academy for Scientific Research the author states that the question of Hijab (Purdah) for Muslim women has been a controversy for centuries and will probably continue for many more. Some learned people do not consider the subject open to discussion and consider that covering the face is required,while a majority are of the opinion that it is not required. A middle line position is taken by some who claim that the instructions are vague and open to individual discretion depending on the situation. The wives of the Prophet (s) were required to cover their faces so that men would not think of them in sexual terms since they were the "Mothers of the Believers" but this requirement was not extended to other women.

15. In 1992 Justice Eusoff of Malaysian High Court delivered a judgment ruling that the freedom of religion guaranteed under Article 11(1) of the Malaysian Constitution was not absolute as Article 11(5) did not authorise any act contrary to any general law relating to public order, public health or morality. The prohibition against wearing attire that covered the face did not affect the appellant's constitutional right to profess and practice her religion. This decision of the Malaysian High Court was confirmed by the Malaysian Supreme Court in 1994. It is, thus, seen from the reported material that there is almost unanimity amongst Muslim scholars that purdah is not essential but covering of head by scarf is obligatory.

16. Even assuming that the Purdah or Gosha is an essential ingredient of the Muslim religion, Article 25 itself makes it clear that this right is subject to public order, morality or health and also to the other provisions of Part III of the Constitution. In T.M.A.Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka, AIR 2003 SC 355, 11 Judges Bench observed as follows: -

" 82. Article 25 gives to all persons the freedom of conscience and the right to freely profess, practice and propagate religion. This right, however, is not absolute. The opening words of Article 25(1) make this right subject to public order, morality and health, and also to the other provisions of Part III of the Constitution. This would mean that the right given to a person under Art.25(1) can be curtailed or regulated if the exercise of that right would violate other provisions of Part III of the Constitution, or if the exercise thereof is not in consonance with public order, morality and health. The general law made by the government contains provisions relating to public order, morality and health; these would have to be complied with, and cannot be violated by any person in exercise of his freedom of conscience or his religion to profess, practice and propagate religion. For example, a person cannot propagate his religion in such a manner as to denigrate another religion or bring about dissatisfaction amongst people.

83. Article 25(2) gives specific power to the State to make any law regulating or restricting any economic, financial, political or other secular activity, which may be associated with religious practice as provided by sub-clause (a) of Article 25(2). This is a further curtailment of the right to profess, practice and propagate religion conferred on the persons under Article 25(1). Article 25(2)(a) covers only a limited area associated with religious practice, in respect of which a law can be made. A careful reading of Article 25(2)(a) indicates that it does not prevent the State from making any law in relation to the religious practice as such. The limited jurisdiction granted by Article 25(2) relates to the making of a law in relation to economic, financial, political or other secular activities associated with the religious practice."

17. In Javed v. State of Haryana, (2003) 8 SCC 369, the provisions of Sections 173(1)(g) and 177(1) of Haryana Panchyati Raj Act, 1994 were challenged before the Supreme Court. The said provisions disqualify a person having more than two living children from holding the specified offices in Panchayats. The Apex Court expressly rejected the submission that the personal law of Muslims permits performance of marriages with four women for the purpose of procreating children and any restriction thereon would be violative of the right to freedom of religion enshrined in Article 25 of the Constitution. The Court observed as follows: -
"60. Looked at from any angle, the challenge to the constitutional validity of Section 175(1)(q) and Section 177(1) must fail. The right to contest an election for any office in Panchayat is neither fundamental nor a common law right. It is the creature of a statute and is obviously subject to qualifications and disqualifications enacted by legislation. It may be permissible for Muslims to enter into four marriages with four women and for anyone whether a Muslim or belonging to any other community or religion to procreate as many children as he likes but no religion in India dictates or mandates as an obligation to enter into bigamy or polygamy or to have children more than one. What is permitted or not prohibited by a religion does not become a religious practice or a positive tenet of a religion. A practice does not acquire the sanction or religion simply because it is permitted. Assuming the practice of having more wives than one or procreating more children than one is a practice followed by any community or group of people, the same can be regulated or prohibited by legislation in the interest of public order, morality and health or by any law providing for social welfare and reform which the impugned legislation clearly does."

61. If anyone chooses to have more living children than two, he is free to do so under the law as it stands now but then he should pay a little price and that is of depriving himself from holding an office in Panchayat in the State of Haryana. There is nothing illegal about it and certainly no unconstitutionality attaches to it."

18. In view of the foregoing discussion, we have no hesitation in holding that the direction of the Commission is not violative of Article 25 of the Constitution. We also do not find any substance in the complaint of violation of right to privacy. In R.Rajagopal v. State of T.N., (1994) 6 SCC 632, the Supreme Court held that the right to privacy is not enumerated as a fundamental right in our Constitution, but has been inferred from Article 21. In that case, reliance was placed on Kharak Singh v. State of U.P., (AIR 1963 SC 1295) and other decisions of English and American Courts, and thereafter, the Court held that the petitioners have a right to publish what they alleged to be a life story/autobiography of Auto Shankar insofar as it appears from the public records, even without his consent or authorisation. But if they go beyond that and publish his life story, they may be invading his right to privacy for the consequences in accordance with law. For this purpose, the Court held that a citizen has a right to safeguard the privacy of his own, his family, marriage, procreation, motherhood, child-bearing and education among other matters. None can publish anything concerning the above matters without his consent whether truthful or otherwise and whether laudatory or critical. Position may, however, be different, if a person voluntarily thrust himself into controversy or voluntarily invites or raises a controversy. The preamble of our Constitution proclaims that we are a democratic republic. The democracy being the basic feature of our constitutional set up, there can be no two opinions that free and fair elections to our legislative bodies alone would guarantee a growth of healthy democracy in our country. The decision of the Election Commission of putting the photographs in the electoral roll was taken with a view to improving the fidelity of the electoral rolls and to check impersonation and eradicate bogus voting. Hence, the argument of the learned counsel that the decision violates the right to privacy is required to be rejected.

19. In Union of India v. Association for Democratic Reforms, AIR 2002 SC 2112, the Supreme Court held that under Article 324, the superintendence, direction and control of the 'conduct of all elections' to Parliament and to the Legislature of every State vests in Election Commission. The phrase 'conduct of elections' is of wide amplitude which would include power to make all necessary provisions for conducting free and fair elections. Article 324 operates in areas left unoccupied by legislation and the words 'superintendence, direction and control' as well as 'conduct of all elections' are the broadest terms. The silence of statute has no exclusionary effect except where it flows from necessary implication. The power of the Commission is plenary in character in exercise thereof. In a statutory provisions or rules, it is known that every contingency could not be foreseen or anticipated with precision, therefore, Commission can cope with situation where the field is unoccupied by issuing necessary orders. The jurisdiction of the Election Commission is wide enough to include all powers necessary for smooth conduct of elections and the word 'elections' is used in a wide sense to include the entire process of election which consists of several stages and embraces many steps. The limitation on plenary character of power is when the Parliament or State Legislature has made a valid law relating to or in connection with elections, the Commission is required to act in conformity with the said provisions. In case where a law is silent, Article 324 is a reservoir of power to act for the avowed purpose of having free and fair election. The Constitution has taken care of leaving scope for exercise of residuary power by the Commission in its own right as a creature of the Constitution in the infinite situations that may emerge from time to time in a large democracy, as every contingency could not be foreseen or anticipated by the enacted laws or the rules. By issuing necessary direction, Commission can fill the vacuum till there is legislation on the subject.

20. Rule 4 of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 clearly provides that the electoral roll for each constituency shall be prepared in such form and in such language or languages as the Election Commission may direct. Therefore, the Election Commission was within its jurisdiction in prescribing a form containing the photographs of the eligible voters. In the result, we find absolutely no substance in the petition and it is hereby dismissed.


ns/pv


To:

1. The Election Commission of India
rep. by its Chief Election Commissioner,
New Delhi-1.

2. Union of India
rep. by its Secretary to Government,
Public (Elections) Department,
New Delhi -1.

3. State of Tamil Nadu,
rep. by its Chief Secretary to Government,
Fort.St.George, Chennai-9.

4. The State Election Commissioner,
Chennai.

5. The District Collector,
Madurai District, Madurai.


[PRV/7940]

Monday, January 11, 2010

ഡി.വൈ.എഫ്‌.ഐയ്‌ക്ക്‌ മനോവൈകൃതം- സക്കറിയ

ഡി.വൈ.എഫ്‌.ഐയ്‌ക്ക്‌ മനോവൈകൃതം- സക്കറിയ
തിരുവനന്തപുരം: കഴിഞ്ഞദിവസം പയ്യന്നൂരില്‍ത്തന്നെ ആക്രമിച്ച ഡി.വൈ.എഫ്‌.ഐ പ്രവര്‍ത്തകര്‍ക്ക്‌ മനോവൈകൃതമാണെന്ന്‌ എഴുത്തുകാരന്‍ സക്കറിയ പ്രതികരിച്ചു. ഒരു പ്രസംഗത്തെ നേരിടേണ്ടത്‌ ഗുണ്ടകളെക്കൊണ്ടാണെന്ന മനോനിലയിലാണ്‌ സി.പി.എം അതിന്റെ യുവജന വിഭാഗത്തെ പരിപോഷിപ്പിക്കുന്നതെങ്കില്‍ ആ പാര്‍ട്ടിയുടെ ഭാവിയെക്കുറിച്ച്‌ തനിക്ക്‌ ആശങ്കയുണ്ടെന്നും സക്കറിയ വ്യക്തമാക്കി.

ബലപ്രയോഗം കൊണ്ട്‌ കാര്യങ്ങളൊക്കെ ശരിയാക്കും എന്ന മട്ടിലാണ്‌ കഴിഞ്ഞദിവസം ഡി.വൈ.എഫ്‌.ഐ പ്രവര്‍ത്തകര്‍ പെരുമാറിയത്‌. ഇതൊരുതരം മനോവൈകൃതവും ഫാഷിസ്റ്റ്‌ സമീപനവുമാണ്‌. ഇത്തരക്കാര്‍ക്ക്‌ ഒരുതരത്തിലുള്ള ബൗദ്ധിക വളര്‍ച്ചയും ഉണ്ടാകുമെന്ന്‌ പ്രതീക്ഷിക്കേണ്ടതില്ല. ഇനിയും സി.പി.എം അധികാരത്തില്‍ വരും. അപ്പോള്‍ തീര്‍ച്ചയായും ഈ ഗുണ്ടകളുടെ പ്രതിനിധികളും എം.എല്‍.എയും മന്ത്രിയുമൊക്കെയാകും. ഒരു മുന്‍ എം.പി. യുടെ മകനാണ്‌ എന്റെ കഴുത്തിനുപിടിച്ചത്‌. അതിന്റെ പേരില്‍ അയാള്‍ക്കൊരു സ്ഥാനം കിട്ടുമെങ്കില്‍ ആയിക്കോട്ടെ. പക്ഷേ ഇത്തരമൊരു മാനസിക നിലയാണ്‌ സി.പി.എം വച്ചുപുലര്‍ത്തുന്നതെങ്കില്‍ ആ പ്രസ്ഥാനത്തിന്റെ ഭാവിയെന്താകും - സക്കറിയ ചോദിച്ചു.

പയ്യന്നൂര്‍ ഗാന്ധിപാര്‍ക്കില്‍ ശനിയാഴ്‌ച വൈകീട്ട്‌ നടന്ന പുസ്‌തക പ്രകാശനച്ചടങ്ങില്‍ സക്കറിയ നടത്തിയ പ്രസംഗമാണ്‌ ഡി.വൈ.എഫ്‌.ഐക്കാരെ പ്രകോപിപ്പിച്ചത്‌. '' പ്രസംഗത്തിന്റെ അവസാനഭാഗത്ത്‌ കമ്മ്യൂണിസ്റ്റ്‌ പ്രസ്ഥാനത്തെക്കുറിച്ച്‌ ഞാന്‍ പരാമര്‍ശിച്ചിരുന്നു. കേരളത്തില്‍ നവോത്ഥാനം കൊണ്ടുവന്ന പ്രസ്ഥാനമാണിത്‌. ആധുനികതയോടും ലൈംഗികതയോടും തുറന്ന സമീപനമായിരുന്നു ഈ പ്രസ്ഥാനത്തിന്‍േറത്‌. സ്‌ത്രീ-പുരുഷ ബന്ധത്തോട്‌ ഒരിക്കലും ഇടുങ്ങിയ സദാചാരം അത്‌ പുലര്‍ത്തിയിരുന്നില്ല. ആ പ്രസ്ഥാനമാണ്‌ ഇപ്പോള്‍ ഒരു പുരുഷന്റെയും സ്‌ത്രീയുടെയും ഭരണഘടനാപരമായ അവകാശങ്ങള്‍ ലംഘിച്ചുകൊണ്ട്‌ പെരുമാറുന്നത്‌. കമ്മ്യൂണിസം കൊണ്ടുവന്ന പുരോഗമന, വിശാല ലോക വീക്ഷണങ്ങള്‍ക്ക്‌ വിരുദ്ധമാണിത്‌. അപ്രകാരം പെരുമാറുന്ന പ്രസ്ഥാനത്തിന്‌ എന്തോ അപചയം സംഭവിച്ചിട്ടുണ്ട്‌. തീര്‍ച്ചയായും കമ്മ്യൂണിസം തകരുന്നത്‌ ഈ നാടിന്‌ നല്ലതല്ല. കമ്മ്യൂണിസം സ്വയം നവീകരണത്തിന്‌ വിധേയമാകണം. ഇടതുപക്ഷത്തിന്‌ ഇവിടെ ശക്തമായൊരു ഇടമുണ്ട്‌....ഇതായിരുന്നു എന്റെ പ്രസംഗത്തിന്റെ സത്ത. പ്രസംഗിച്ചു കഴിഞ്ഞപ്പോള്‍ അവിടെയുണ്ടായിരുന്ന പു.ക.സ പ്രവര്‍ത്തകന്‍ എന്നോട്‌ മോശമായി സംസാരിച്ചു. തുടര്‍ന്ന്‌ ഗുണ്ടകളെപ്പോലെ തോന്നിക്കുന്ന കുറേ ആള്‍ക്കാര്‍ എന്നെ തടഞ്ഞുവെയ്‌ക്കുകുയും മുന്‍ എം.പിയുടെ മകന്‍ കഴുത്തിനു പിടിക്കുകയും ചെയ്‌തു - സക്കറിയ പറഞ്ഞു.
സക്കറിയക്കു നേരെയുള്ള കൈയേറ്റം അപലപനീയം: പു.ക.സ. ( 11 Jan 2010 )
സക്കറിയയെ കൈയേറ്റം ചെയ്‌തതില്‍ പ്രതിഷേധം ( 11 Jan 2010 )
കൈയേറ്റത്തെ അപലപിക്കുന്നു; സക്കറിയയുടെ കാഴ്‌ചപ്പാടിനോട്‌ യോജിപ്പില്ല-ഡി. വൈ. എഫ്‌. ഐ. ( 11 Jan 2010 )
സക്കറിയയെ കൈയേറ്റം ചെയ്‌തത്‌ അപലപനീയം -മന്ത്രി ബേബി ( 11 Jan 2010 )
ഡി.വൈ.എഫ്‌.ഐ.യുടേത്‌ ഫാസിസ്റ്റ്‌ രീതി- പി.കെ.കുഞ്ഞാലിക്കുട്ടി ( 11 Jan 2010 )
സക്കറിയയ്‌ക്കെതിരെയുള്ള കൈയേറ്റം അംഗീകരിക്കാനാവില്ല -കെ.വി. തോമസ്‌ ( 11 Jan 2010 )

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

ചങ്കൂറ്റമുണ്ടെങ്കില്‍ പറഞ്ഞ നുണ സ്ഥാപിക്കട്ടെ

ദീപിക മുഖപ്രസംഗം, 2007 ജൂലൈ 27 (ഓണ്‍ലൈന്‍ ആര്‍ക്കൈവ് ലഭ്യമല്ല)

ദീപിക ദിനപത്രത്തിന്റെ സാരഥ്യം ഏല്‍ക്കുക എന്നത് അക്ഷന്തവ്യമായ ഒരപരാധമാണോ, അഥവാ ദീപിക ചെയര്‍മാന്‍സ്ഥാനം ഏല്‍ക്കുന്നയാള്‍ ക്രിമിനലും കല്ലെറിയപ്പെടേണ്ടവനുമാണോ? ആണെന്ന് ചിത്തസ്ഥിരതയുള്ളവര്‍ പറയില്ല. എന്നാല്‍, അങ്ങനെയാണ് എന്നു സ്ഥാപിച്ചെടുക്കാന്‍ കേരളത്തിലെ മാധ്യമരംഗത്ത് പ്രവര്‍ത്തിക്കുന്ന ചില നീചബുദ്ധികള്‍ക്ക് സദാ നിര്‍ബന്ധമുണ്ട് എന്നുവേണം കരുതാന്‍. ഞങ്ങളുടെ ചെയര്‍മാനായിരുന്ന കാഞ്ഞിരപ്പള്ളി രൂപതാധ്യക്ഷന്‍ അഭിവന്ദ്യ പിതാവ് മാര്‍ മാത്യു അറയ്ക്കല്‍ ദീപികയുടെ സാരഥ്യം ഏറ്റ നാള്‍മുതല്‍ക്ക് തന്നെ അദ്ദേഹത്തിനെതിരേ അങ്ങേയറ്റം ഹീനമായ അപവാദപ്രചാരണമാണ് കേരളത്തിലെ ചില നാലാംകിട പ്രസിദ്ധീകരണങ്ങള്‍ അഴിച്ചുവിട്ടത്.

ദീപിക ചെയര്‍മാന്‍ എന്നതിലുപരി, സാമൂഹിക പരിഷ്കര്‍ത്താവും പതിനായിരക്കണക്കിനു നിരാധാരര്‍ക്ക് സഹായഹസ്തവും അനേകലക്ഷം വിശ്വാസികള്‍ക്ക് ആത്മീയ ഇടയനും ആയ ആ വൈദിക ശ്രേഷ്ഠനെ ആക്ഷേപിക്കാന്‍ തരംതാണ ആരോപണങ്ങളിലൂടെ തുനിഞ്ഞിറങ്ങിയ ചില പ്രസിദ്ധീകരണങ്ങള്‍ അദ്ദേഹം തല്‍്സ്ഥാനം ഒഴിയുംവരെ തങ്ങളുടെ ദുഷ്പ്രചാരണങ്ങളും തുടര്‍ന്നു. ഇന്നിപ്പോള്‍ എം.എ. ഫാരിസ് ദീപികയുടെ ചെയര്‍മാന്‍സ്ഥാനം ഏറ്റ് ഏതാനും ദിവസങ്ങള്‍മാത്രം തികയുമ്പോള്‍ ആക്രമണത്തിന്റെ മുന അദ്ദേഹത്തിനു നേര്‍ക്കും തിരിയുകയാണ്.

ഇങ്ങനെ ദീപിക കുടുംബത്തിനും അതിന്റെ സാരഥ്യം ഏല്‍ക്കുന്ന വ്യക്തിയുടെ നേര്‍ക്കു പ്രത്യേകിച്ചും വ്യാജപ്രചാരണം അഴിച്ചുവിടുക എന്ന ഗൂഢതന്ത്രത്തിന്റെ വൃത്തികെട്ട മുഖവുമായാണ് ഇക്കഴിഞ്ഞ ദിവസത്തെ മാതൃഭൂമി ദിനപത്രം പ്രത്യക്ഷപ്പെട്ടത്.

ആസൂത്രിതവും ലക്ഷണയുക്തവുമായ വ്യക്തിഹത്യാനീക്കത്തിന്റെ എല്ലാ സംശയങ്ങളും സാധൂകരിക്കപ്പെടുംവിധം ഇന്ത്യാവിഷന്‍ തുടങ്ങി ചില ചാനലുകളും, മാതൃഭൂമിയുടെ നിറംപിടിപ്പിച്ച നുണകള്‍ ഏറ്റെടുത്ത് പ്രേക്ഷകര്‍ക്ക് ആവര്‍ത്തിച്ചാവര്‍ത്തിച്ച് എറിഞ്ഞുകൊടുക്കുന്ന നാണംകെട്ട കാഴ്ചയാണ് പിന്നീട് അരങ്ങേറിയത്. ആര്‍ക്കെതിരേയും യാതൊരടിസ്ഥാനവുമില്ലാതെ എന്തു ദുഷ്പ്രചാരണവും നടത്താമെന്ന നെറികെട്ട മാധ്യമധാര്‍ഷ്ട്യത്തിന്റെ മകുടോദാഹരണമായിപ്പോയി ഈ കാഴ്ച.

യശഃശരീരനായ മുന്‍ മുഖ്യമന്ത്രി ഇ.കെ. നായനാരുടെ സ്മരണാര്‍ഥം ഈയിടെ കണ്ണൂരില്‍ നടന്ന ഫുട്ബോള്‍ മത്സരത്തിന്റെ സംഘാടകകമ്മിറ്റിക്ക് ദീപിക ചെയര്‍മാന്‍കൂടിയായ എം.എ. ഫാരിസ്, തന്റെ ചെന്നൈയിലെ വ്യവസായ സ്ഥാപനം വകയായി ഒരു വലിയ തുക സംഭാവന ചെയ്തിരിക്കുന്നു എന്നാണ് ആരോപണത്തിനാധാരമായി മാതൃഭൂമി കാണുന്നത്. തുക നല്കിയിരിക്കുന്നത് കള്ളപ്പണമായല്ലെന്നും ബാങ്ക് അക്കൌണ്ട് വഴി നിയമാനുസൃതം രേഖാമൂലംതന്നെയാണെന്നും മാതൃഭൂമിതന്നെ പറയുന്നുവെങ്കിലും അതില്‍ പക്ഷേ, ദുരൂഹതയുണ്ടന്നും എന്തോ ഗൂഢോദ്ദേശ്യമുണ്െടന്നും സ്വയം ഖണ്ഡനത്തിലൂടെ സ്ഥാപിച്ചെടുക്കുന്നതിലാണ് മാതൃഭൂമിയുടെ കുറ്റാന്വേഷകര്‍ പണിപ്പെട്ടിരിക്കുന്നത്.

പരസ്യമുദ്ദേശിച്ചോ സ്പോണ്‍സര്‍ഷിപ്പ് ആയോ അല്ല ഫാരിസ് പ്രസ്തുത തുക മത്സരകമ്മിറ്റിക്ക് കൊടുത്തിട്ടുള്ളത് എന്നതത്രേ മാതൃഭൂമി മിനക്കെട്ട് ചികഞ്ഞെടുത്ത സാമ്പത്തിക കുറ്റകൃത്യം. ഒരു വ്യക്തി, പ്രത്യേകിച്ച് കേരളത്തിലെ ഫുട്ബോള്‍ കളിയുടെ ഈറ്റില്ലമായ മലബാറില്‍ ജനിച്ചുവളര്‍ന്ന ആള്‍ സ്പോര്‍ട്സ് വികസനത്തിനായി നീക്കിവച്ചിട്ടുള്ള ഒരു തുക വ്യവസ്ഥാപിതവും നിയമാനുസൃതവുമായ മാര്‍ഗത്തിലൂടെ മാത്രം രേഖാമൂലം അതിനു വിനിയോഗിച്ചാല്‍ അതു സാമ്പത്തിക കുറ്റമാവുമോ? അത് ഏതു നിയമപ്രകാരം, അഥവാ അതിനു ദുരൂഹത കല്പിക്കാന്‍ ആര്‍ക്ക് എന്തധികാരം. അതില്‍ ഗൂഢലക്ഷ്യം ആരോപിക്കുന്ന മാതൃഭൂമിക്കും ഇന്ത്യാവിഷന്‍ എന്ന പിണിയാളുകള്‍ക്കും എന്തിനിത്ര ആവേശം.

സ്വന്തം നാട്ടില്‍ നടക്കുന്ന ഒരു സല്‍ക്കാര്യത്തിന് ഒരു വ്യക്തി നിയമങ്ങളെ മാനിച്ചുതന്നെ സഹായമെത്തിക്കുമ്പോള്‍ പ്രസ്തുത സഹായകാര്യം വാര്‍ത്തയോ പരസ്യമോ ആക്കി ജനസമക്ഷം കൊട്ടിഘോഷിക്കേണ്ട എന്ന് ഒരു വ്യക്തി നിര്‍ബന്ധപൂര്‍വം നിഷ്കര്‍ഷിച്ചാല്‍ അതു മാന്യതയായല്ലേ കണക്കാക്കപ്പെടേണ്ടത്. അഥവാ ഒരു വ്യക്തി തന്റെ സ്വന്തം പണംമുടക്കി നിയമവിധേയമായ സഹായം ചെയ്യുമ്പോള്‍ അതില്‍ പരസ്യപ്പെടുത്തലോ മേനിനടിക്കലോ ആവശ്യമില്ലെന്ന് പ്രസ്തുത വ്യക്തി തീരുമാനിച്ചാല്‍ അന്യന്റെ പണച്ചെലവില്‍ നിത്യേന സ്വന്തം മുഖം മാതൃഭൂമിയുടെ മുന്‍പേജില്‍ പൊതുദര്‍ശത്തിനുവയ്ക്കുന്ന മാതൃഭൂമി എം.ഡി.യും കൂട്ടരും അതില്‍ കുണ്ഠിതപ്പെടേണ്ടതുണ്േടാ. ബുദ്ധിയും വിവേചനവും ഉള്ളവര്‍ ചിന്തിച്ചു തീരുമാനിക്കട്ടെ.

സിംഗപ്പൂര്‍ ആസ്ഥാനമായുള്ള നാഷണല്‍ കിഡ്നിഫൌണ്േടഷനുമായി ബന്ധപ്പെടുത്തിയാണു ദീപിക ചെയര്‍മാന്‍ എം.എ. ഫാരിസിനെതിരേ മറ്റൊരു തേജോവധശ്രമം ആരംഭിച്ചിട്ടുള്ളത്. എം.എ. ഫാരിസിനെ കിഡ്നി ഫൌണ്േടഷന്‍ കുംഭകോണത്തില്‍ കുറ്റംചുമത്തി പിഴയടപ്പിച്ചു , മാപ്പുപറയിച്ചു എന്ന നാണംകെട്ട അസത്യം സ്വന്തം പേജില്‍ അച്ചടിച്ച മാതൃഭൂമി എന്ന വലിയ ദിനപത്രം സ്വയം മലീമസമാവുന്നത് എത്രയോ ദയനീയമായ കാര്യമാണ്.

ദേശീയ ദിനപത്രമെന്ന മഹാപാരമ്പര്യത്തിന്റെ പേരില്‍ അവസരത്തിലും അനവസരത്തിലും മേനി നടിക്കുന്ന മാതൃഭൂമിയുടെ നുണക്കൊഴുപ്പില്‍ അവരുടെ ഏതെങ്കിലും നിഷ്കളങ്ക വായനക്കാര്‍ വഞ്ചിക്കപ്പെട്ടുപോയിട്ടുണ്െടങ്കില്‍ അവര്‍ക്കായി മാത്രം ചോദിക്കട്ടെ, സിംഗപ്പൂര്‍ കിഡ്നി ഫൌണ്േടഷനുമായി ബന്ധപ്പെട്ട് ഒരു വ്യാപാരത്തര്‍ക്കം നിലനിന്നിരുന്നു എന്നതല്ലാതെ സിംഗപ്പൂരു പോലെ കഠിന നിയമവ്യവസ്ഥ നിലവിലുള്ള ഒരു രാജ്യത്ത് എം.എ. ഫാരിസിനെതിരേ സിംഗപ്പൂര്‍ ഗവണ്‍ മെന്റോ പോലീസോ ഏതെങ്കിലുമൊരു സര്‍ക്കാര്‍ അന്വേഷണഏജന്‍സിയോ ഏതെങ്കിലുമൊരു കോടതിയോ എന്തെങ്കിലും ഒരു ക്രിമിനല്‍ കുറ്റം ചുമത്തിയിട്ടുള്ളതായോ എന്തിന്, വിചാരണക്കൂട്ടില്‍ നിര്‍ത്തിയതായെങ്കിലുമോ തെളിയിക്കുവാന്‍ മാതൃഭൂമിക്കു കഴിയുമോ?

ഏതെങ്കിലുമൊരു കേസില്‍ ഫാരിസിനെ ശിക്ഷിച്ചതായോ മാപ്പു പറയിച്ചതായോ പിഴയടപ്പിച്ചതായോ എന്തെങ്കിലുമൊരു വിശ്വാസ്യമായ രേഖയുടെ ബലത്തില്‍ വായനക്കാര്‍ സമക്ഷം സ്ഥാപിച്ച് സമര്‍ത്ഥിക്കുവാന്‍ മാതൃഭൂമിക്കു നട്ടെല്ലുണ്ടാവുമോ? ഉണ്ടാവുമെങ്കില്‍ ഇതേ പംക്തിയിലൂടെ മാതൃഭൂമിയോടും അതിന്റെ ദുഷ്പ്രചാരണ ചൂടുചോറു വാരിയ ഇന്ത്യാവിഷനോടും പരസ്യക്ഷമാപണം നടത്താന്‍ മലയാളഭാഷയിലെ ഏറ്റവും പ്രായംചെന്ന ഈ പത്രം സന്നദ്ധമായിരിക്കും. മറിച്ച് അപ്രകാരം തെളിവോ രേഖകളോ ഹാജരാക്കാന്‍ കഴിവില്ലെങ്കില്‍ ഇന്റര്‍നെറ്റിലൂടെ നിമിഷംപ്രതി പ്രചരിക്കുന്ന വ്യാജവൃത്താന്തങ്ങളെ പൊലിപ്പിച്ചെടുത്ത് സ്വന്തം എം.ഡിയുടെയും പുത്രന്റെയും സ്വേച്ഛാപരമായ രാഷ്ട്രീയവൈരനിര്യാതനബുദ്ധിക്കു വഴിപാടര്‍പ്പിക്കുക എന്ന അക്ഷന്തവ്യമായ മൂഢത്വത്തിന് മാപ്പു പറയാനും മാതൃഭൂമിയുടെ വിശ്വാസ്യതയ്ക്കു ഇന്നും വിലകല്പിക്കുന്ന വായനക്കാരോടു ക്ഷമാപണം പറയാനും പോന്ന മാധ്യമ മാന്യത മാതൃഭൂമി പ്രകടിപ്പിക്കുമോ?

ഞങ്ങളുടെ ചെയര്‍മാന്‍ എംഎ ഫാരിസിനെതിരേ മുന്‍പും ചില അധമ പ്രസിദ്ധീകരണങ്ങള്‍ ചില ദുരാരോപണങ്ങള്‍ കെട്ടിച്ചമച്ച് എഴുതിച്ചിട്ടുണ്ട്. ദീപികയില്‍നിന്നു നിത്യേന ലക്ഷക്കണക്കിനു വായനക്കാരിലെത്തുന്ന പ്രഭാതപത്രത്തിലൂടെയോ, രാഷ്ട്രദീപിക സാഹാഹ്നപത്രത്തിലൂടെയോ അത്തരം ആരോപണങ്ങള്‍ക്കു മറുപടി പറയുക ഞങ്ങളെ സംബന്ധിച്ചിടത്തോളം എത്രയും എളുപ്പമായ കാര്യവുമാണ്. എന്നാല്‍, അത്തരം പ്രചാരണങ്ങളെയെല്ലാം അവ അര്‍ഹിക്കുന്ന അവജ്ഞ കല്പിച്ച് അവഗണിക്കുക എന്നതാണ് സമചിത്തതയില്‍ അധിഷ്ഠിതമായ ഞങ്ങളുടെ എഡിറ്റോറിയല്‍ നയം.

എന്നാല്‍, മാതൃഭൂമിയെപ്പോലെ വിശ്വാസ്യതയും ബഹുമാന്യതയുമുണ്െടന്നു ഞങ്ങള്‍ മതിക്കുന്ന പത്രം തികച്ചും നിര്‍ഭാഗ്യവശാല്‍ അതിന്റെ തലപ്പത്തെത്തിപ്പെട്ട ചിലരുടെ ഹീനതാത്പര്യങ്ങളെ മുന്‍നിര്‍ത്തി ഈവിധം വ്യക്തിഹത്യയ്ക്കു മുതിരുമ്പോള്‍ ഞങ്ങളുടെയും അവരുടെയും വായനക്കാരെ സത്യമറിയിക്കേണ്ടത് പത്രധര്‍മം എന്ന് വിശ്വസിക്കുന്നു.

മാതൃഭൂമിയുടെ പിന്നിലായി എം.എ ഫാരിസിനുമേല്‍ നിഗൂഢതയുടെ പരിവേഷം ചാര്‍ത്താന്‍ ഒരുമ്പെട്ടിറങ്ങിയ ഇന്ത്യാ വിഷന്‍ ചാനല്‍ ഫാരിസിന്റെ ഒരു ഫോട്ടോപോലും ലഭ്യമല്ല എന്നത്രേ പ്രേക്ഷകരോട് വിലപിച്ചത്.

പാസ്പോര്‍ട്ടിനും പാന്‍കാര്‍ഡിനും വോട്ടവകാശത്തിനും റേഷന്‍കാര്‍ഡിനും ഡ്രൈവിംഗ് ലൈസന്‍സിനും ബാങ്ക് അക്കൌണ്ട് തുറക്കുന്നതിനും കമ്പനി നടത്തിപ്പിനും എന്തിന്, സെല്‍ ഫോണ്‍ വരിക്കാരാകുന്നതിനുപോലും വ്യക്തികള്‍ തങ്ങളുടെ ഫോട്ടോ ഹാജരാക്കണമെന്നു നിര്‍ബന്ധ നിയമവ്യവസ്ഥയുള്ള ഒരു രാജ്യത്ത് ഇപ്പറഞ്ഞതെല്ലാമുള്ള ഒരാളുടെ ഫോട്ടോ ഇന്ത്യാവിഷനിലെ അപസര്‍പ്പകന്മാര്‍ക്ക് ലഭ്യമാവാതെ പോയത് എങ്ങനെ ഫാരിസിന്റെ കുറ്റമാവും. അഥവാ നിത്യേനയെന്നോണം തങ്ങളുടെ ഫോട്ടോ പത്രത്തിന്റെ മുന്‍പേജില്‍ നിരത്താന്‍ പരസ്പരം മത്സരിക്കുന്ന മാതൃഭൂമി എം.ഡിക്കും അദ്ദേഹത്തിന്റെ പുത്രനും മാത്രം അവകാശപ്പെട്ട ആ നാണംകെട്ട മനോരോഗം ദീപിക ചെയര്‍മാനു പിടിപെട്ടിട്ടില്ല എന്നതാണ് ഇന്ത്യാവിഷന്റെ പരിതാപമെങ്കില്‍ ആ ആക്ഷേപത്തെ ഞങ്ങള്‍ അഭിമാനപൂര്‍വം സ്വാഗതം ചെയ്യുന്നു.

കളങ്കിതമായ അഴിമതിപ്പണംകൊണ്ടും ബ്ളേഡ് പലിശകൊണ്ടും വാര്‍ത്താചാനല്‍ വാണിഭം നടത്തുന്നവര്‍ക്ക് അത്തരമൊരഭിമാനബോധം പക്ഷേ, ദഹിച്ചുകൊള്ളണമെന്നില്ല. എം.എ. ഫാരിസിന്റെ മേല്‍ കുറ്റംചാര്‍ത്തി ശിക്ഷാവിധി നടപ്പിലാക്കാന്‍ വൃഥാ വിയര്‍പ്പൊഴുക്കുന്ന മാതൃഭൂമിയോടും ഇന്ത്യാവിഷനിലെ അതിന്റെ പരിചാരകരോടും ഒരിക്കല്‍ക്കൂടി സധൈര്യം, സുദൃഢം ഞങ്ങള്‍ പറയട്ടെ, ദീപിക ചെയര്‍മാന്‍ എംഎ ഫാരിസിനെതിരേ ഈ രാജ്യത്ത് കേന്ദ്രഗവണ്‍മെന്റോ അതിന്റെ അന്വേഷണ ഏജന്‍സികളോ സെയില്‍സ് ടാക്സ്, ഇന്‍കംടാക്സ്, എക്സൈസ്, കസ്റ്റംസ്, എന്‍ഫോഴ്സ്മെന്റ് തുടങ്ങിയ ഏതെങ്കിലും വകുപ്പോ, ഈ രാജ്യത്തെ ഏതെങ്കിലും സംസ്ഥാനസര്‍ക്കാരോ പോലീസോ ഏതെങ്കിലുമൊരു നീതിപീഠമോ എന്തെങ്കിലും ഒരു കുറ്റാരോപണം നടത്തിയതായി അഥവാ ശിക്ഷിച്ചതായി അഥവാ ഒരന്വേഷണത്തിന് ഉത്തരവിട്ടതായി എന്തിന് ഒരു നോട്ടീസെങ്കിലും അയച്ചതായി രേഖാമൂലം സ്ഥാപിക്കുവാന്‍ നിങ്ങളിലാര്‍ക്കെങ്കിലും ചങ്കൂറ്റമുണ്ടാവുമോ.

അല്ലെങ്കില്‍ നിങ്ങളിലാരെയെങ്കിലുംപോലെ ഈര്‍ക്കിലി രാഷ്ട്രീയ ബലത്തിന്റെയോ അധികാരത്തിന്റെയോ മന്ത്രിപ്പണിയുടെയോ കള്ളക്കരാറുകളുടെയോ പേരില്‍ എന്തെങ്കിലും ഒരു ആനുകൂല്യം നേടിയെടുത്തതായി സ്ഥാപിക്കാന്‍ നിങ്ങള്‍ക്കു കഴിയുമോ.

അങ്ങനെ കഴിയുമെങ്കില്‍ അതു വായനക്കാര്‍ക്കും പൊതുസമൂഹത്തിനും മുന്നില്‍ നിവര്‍ത്തിച്ചെടുക്കാന്‍ മലയാളഭാഷയിലെ ഏറ്റവും പഴക്കവും പാരമ്പര്യവുമുള്ള ഈ ദിനപത്രം നിങ്ങ ളെ വെല്ലുവിളിക്കുന്നു. ഇങ്ങനെ ഒരു തുറന്ന വെല്ലുവിളിക്ക് പോന്ന ധാര്‍മിക ബലവും തന്റേടവും നിങ്ങളിലാര്‍ക്കുണ്ട് അവകാശപ്പെടാന്‍. ഇല്ല എന്നതല്ലേ സത്യം.

എം.എ. ഫാരിസിനെതിരേ വ്യാജവാര്‍ത്താ പ്രചാരണം നടത്തിയ ഓരോരുത്തര്‍ക്കുമെതിരേ സാധ്യമായ എല്ലാ നിയമനടപടികളും വരുംദിനങ്ങളില്‍ സ്വീകരിക്കപ്പെടുമെന്നും അപകീര്‍ത്തി വ്യവസായത്തിന്റെ പ്രതിപുരുഷന്മാരായ മാതൃഭൂമിയിലെയും ഇന്ത്യാവിഷനിലെയും വ്യജവാര്‍ത്താ പ്രചാരകര്‍ക്ക് അര്‍ഹമായ ശിക്ഷ വാങ്ങിക്കൊടുക്കാന്‍ ഞങ്ങള്‍ പ്രതിജ്ഞാബദ്ധരാണെന്നും ഇതിനാല്‍ നിസംശയം ഓര്‍മിപ്പിച്ചുകൊള്ളട്ടെ.

സക്കാത്തിനെത്തി, പത്രമുടമയായി...

മാതൃഭൂമി, ജൂലൈ 27

തിരുവനന്തപുരം: അമ്പത്തിമൂന്ന്‌ കോടി രൂപയുടെ സാമ്പത്തിക തട്ടിപ്പില്‍പ്പെട്ട്‌ സിംഗപ്പൂരിലെ നാഷണല്‍ കിഡ്‌നി ഫൗണ്ടേഷന്‍ പ്രതിസന്ധിയിലായത്‌ വ്യവസായി ഫാരീസ്‌ അബൂബക്കറുമായുള്ള കരാറിനെ തുടര്‍ന്നാണെന്ന്‌ സ്ഥാപനത്തിന്റെ ഓഡിറ്റ്‌ രേഖകള്‍ വ്യക്തമാക്കുന്നു.

കമ്പനി സി.ഇ.ഒ. ടി.ടി. ദുരൈയുമായുള്ള ഉറ്റ സൗഹൃദവും ഡയറക്ടര്‍ബോര്‍ഡംഗമായ മറ്റില്‍ഡാച്ചവയുമായുള്ള ബിസിനസ്‌ ബന്ധങ്ങളുമാണ്‌ 32 കോടിയില്‌പരം രൂപയുടെ കരാര്‍ എല്‍.കെ.എഫുമായി ഉണ്ടാക്കാന്‍ ഇദ്ദേഹത്തിന്‌ തുണയായത്‌.

കിഡ്‌നി ഫൗണ്ടേഷന്‍ അധികൃതരുമായി ഫാരീസ്‌ വളര്‍ത്തിയെടുത്ത അതേ സൗഹൃദമാണ്‌ സി.പി.എമ്മിന്റെ സംസ്ഥാനത്തെ ചില ഉന്നത നേതാക്കളുമായും അദ്ദേഹത്തിനുള്ളത്‌. നായനാര്‍ ഫുട്‌ബോള്‍ മേളയ്‌ക്ക്‌ സംഭാവനയായി ഫാരീസ്‌ 60 ലക്ഷം രൂപ നല്‍കിയത്‌ ഈ വസ്‌തുതയിലേക്കാണ്‌ വിരല്‍ചൂണ്ടുന്നത്‌. ബുധനാഴ്‌ച ഫുട്‌ബോള്‍ മേളയുടെ പിരിവിനെക്കുറിച്ച്‌ സി.പി.എം. നേതൃത്വം വിശദീകരണം പുറത്തിറക്കിയെങ്കിലും 60 ലക്ഷം രൂപ അദ്ദേഹം നല്‍കാനുള്ള സഹാചര്യമോ, പാര്‍ട്ടിയുമായി അദ്ദേഹത്തിനുള്ള ബന്ധമോ വ്യക്തമാക്കിയിട്ടില്ല.

സംസ്ഥാനത്തെ ആദ്യ ദിനപത്രമായ 'ദീപിക' ഫാരീസിന്റെ കൈവശം എത്തിയതിന്‌ പിന്നിലും ദുരൂഹതയുണ്ട്‌. കേരളത്തിലെ ക്രൈസ്‌തവരുടെ മുഖപത്രമായിരുന്ന ദീപിക സി.എം.ഐ. വൈദികരുടെ നേതൃത്വത്തില്‍ നിന്ന്‌ കൈമാറ്റം ചെയ്യപ്പെട്ടപ്പോള്‍ പത്രത്തിന്റെ ഉള്ളക്കടത്തിലും ഏറെ മാറ്റം വന്നു. സി.പി.എം. വിഭാഗീയതയില്‍ ഔദ്യോഗിക പക്ഷത്ത്‌ നിലയുറപ്പിച്ച ദീപിക, രണ്ട്‌ വര്‍ഷമായി വി.എസ്‌. അച്യുതാനന്ദനെ നിരന്തരമായി അക്രമിക്കുന്നതിന്‌ പിന്നിലും പാര്‍ട്ടിയിലെ ഒരു വിഭാഗവുമായുള്ള സൗഹൃദമാണെന്ന്‌ അനുമാനിക്കാം.

2004ലാണ്‌ ഫാരീസ്‌ അബൂബക്കര്‍ ദീപികയില്‍ കൈകടത്തി തുടങ്ങിയത്‌. 'ദീപിക' ചെയര്‍മാനായ കാഞ്ഞിരപ്പള്ളി ബിഷപ്പ്‌ മാര്‍ മാത്യു അറയ്‌ക്കലിന്റെ സുഹൃത്തായിട്ടായിരുന്നു അദ്ദേഹത്തിന്റെ കടന്നുവരവ്‌. സഭയ്‌ക്ക്‌ പുറത്തുള്ള ആര്‍ക്കും 'ദീപിക'യുടെ ഓഹരി നല്‍കേണ്ടതില്ലെന്ന്‌ 2005 നവംബറില്‍ കൂടിയ ജനറല്‍ബോഡി തീരുമാനമെടുത്തിട്ടും ഫാരീസിന്‌ ഇഷ്ടംപോലെ ഓഹരികള്‍ ലഭിച്ചു. കത്തോലിക്കാ സഭാംഗമല്ലെങ്കിലും അത്രയ്‌ക്ക്‌ അരക്കിട്ടുറപ്പിച്ചതായിരുന്നു അദ്ദേഹത്തിന്റെ ബന്ധങ്ങള്‍. 2005 ഡിസംബറില്‍ 'ദീപിക'യുടെ ഡയറക്ടര്‍ബോര്‍ഡ്‌ യോഗം ചെന്നൈയില്‍ വിളിച്ചുകൂട്ടിയാണ്‌ ഈ തീരുമാനമെടുത്തത്‌.

ദീപികയില്‍ പ്രതിഷേധം ശക്തമാവുകയും സഭയില്‍ വന്‍ ഒച്ചപ്പാട്‌ ഉണ്ടാകുകയും ചെയ്‌തപ്പോള്‍ മാര്‍ മാത്യു അറയ്‌ക്കല്‍ എല്ലാ കത്തോലിക്കാ ബിഷപ്പുമാര്‍ക്കും ഒരു കത്തയച്ചു- ''ദീപിക'യുടെ പ്രതിസന്ധിയില്‍ പത്രത്തെ സഹായിക്കാന്‍ ഒരു കോടി രൂപ തന്ന്‌ സഹായിച്ച ഒരു നല്ല സുഹൃത്താണ്‌ ഫാരീസ്‌. രണ്ട്‌ വര്‍ഷത്തിനുള്ളില്‍ പണം മടക്കിനല്‍കണം. ഇനി പണം തിരിച്ചുകൊടുക്കാനായില്ലെങ്കില്‍ അദ്ദേഹമത്‌ സക്കാത്തായി കരുതിക്കൊള്ളും''.

സക്കാത്തിനായി വന്നയാള്‍ പത്രമുടമയായി മാറുന്നതിന്‌ കാലതാമസം ഉണ്ടായിരുന്നില്ല. 9.5 കോടിയുടെ ഓഹരി ഇതിനകം അദ്ദേഹത്തിന്റെ പേരിലേക്ക്‌ മാറ്റിയിരുന്നു. പണം മടക്കി നല്‍കി പത്രം തിരിച്ചുപിടിക്കാന്‍ ഇതിനിടെ സഭ പലവട്ടം ശ്രമിച്ചു. ആദ്യം നാല്‌ കോടിയും പിന്നീട്‌ എട്ട്‌കോടിയും കൊടുത്താല്‍ ഫാരീസ്‌ ഒഴിവായിക്കൊള്ളുമെന്ന്‌ ഇടനില നിന്ന ബിഷപ്പ്‌ അറിയിച്ചു. എന്നാല്‍ പണവുമായി ചെന്നപ്പോഴൊക്കെ ഓരോ കാരണം പറഞ്ഞ്‌ അദ്ദേഹം ഒഴിഞ്ഞുമാറി. ഒടുവില്‍ 10 കോടി രൂപ കൊടുത്ത്‌ ഓഹരികള്‍ തിരിച്ചുവാങ്ങാന്‍ സഭ തീരുമാനിച്ചു. ഓരോ അതിരൂപതയും രണ്ട്‌ കോടി രൂപവെച്ച്‌ വിഹിതം വഹിക്കാനും തീരുമാനമായി. എന്നാല്‍ പണം സംഭരിച്ചപ്പോള്‍ ''തനിക്ക്‌ അല്‍മായരുടെ പണം വേണ്ട'' എന്ന വിചിത്രമായ ന്യായം ഉന്നയിച്ചതിനെ തുടര്‍ന്ന്‌ ആ നീക്കവും നടന്നില്ല.

എന്നാല്‍ ഇതിനിടെ 'ദീപിക'യുടെ കൊച്ചിയിലെയും ആലുവ പാതാളത്തെയും 20 കോടിയെങ്കിലും വിലവരുന്ന വസ്‌തുവും കെട്ടിടവും ഫാരീസ്‌ അഞ്ചര കോടിക്ക്‌ വാങ്ങി. ദീപിക കമ്പനി തങ്ങള്‍ക്ക്‌ ഇനി തിരിച്ചുകിട്ടില്ലെന്ന്‌ ഏതാണ്ട്‌ ഉറപ്പായപ്പോള്‍ പ്രഭാത ദിനപത്രവും 'കുട്ടികളുടെ ദീപിക'യും കോട്ടയം ഓഫീസും മാത്രം പണം കൊടുത്ത്‌ സഭയെടുത്ത്‌ ബാക്കി ഫാരീസിന്‌ വിട്ടുകൊടുക്കാന്‍ ധാരണയായി. ഇത്‌ സംബന്ധിച്ച കരാറില്‍ കര്‍ദ്ദിനാള്‍ മാര്‍ വര്‍ക്കി വിതയത്തിലും ഫാരീസ്‌ അബൂബക്കറും കഴിഞ്ഞ മാര്‍ച്ച്‌ 26ന്‌ ഒപ്പിട്ടു.

മാര്‍ച്ച്‌ 29ന്‌ ജനറല്‍ബോഡി വിളിച്ചുചേര്‍ത്ത്‌ കൈമാറ്റം അംഗീകരിപ്പിക്കാന്‍ നിശ്ചയിച്ചിരുന്നെങ്കിലും 28ന്‌ കോടതിയുടെ വിലക്ക്‌ വന്നു. തുടര്‍ന്ന്‌ യോഗം മാറ്റിവെച്ചു.

കത്തോലിക്കാ സഭയുടെ നിലപാടുകള്‍ക്ക്‌ എന്നും പിന്തുണ നല്‍കിവന്ന പത്രം എന്നേക്കുമായി കൈവിട്ടുപോകുന്നതിനെതിരെയുള്ള അവസാന ചെറുത്തുനില്‌പിലാണ്‌ ഓഹരി ഉടമകള്‍. 22000ഓളം ഓഹരിയുടമകള്‍ ഉള്ളതില്‍ പലരും ചേര്‍ന്ന്‌ ഒപ്പുശേഖരണം നടത്തി ഓഹരി കൈമാറ്റത്തിനെതിരെ നിയമനടപടികളിലേക്ക്‌ നീങ്ങുകയാണ്‌.

കര്‍ദ്ദിനാള്‍ മാര്‍ വര്‍ക്കി വിതയത്തില്‍, ആര്‍ച്ച്‌ബിഷപ്പ്‌ മാര്‍ ജോസഫ്‌ പൗവ്വത്തില്‍ എന്നിങ്ങനെ കത്തോലിക്കാ സഭയിലെ ഏറ്റവും ശക്തരായ ബിഷപ്പുമാര്‍ ഇടപെട്ടിട്ടും ദീപിക കൈവിട്ടുപോകുന്നത്‌ തടയാന്‍ സഭയ്‌ക്ക്‌ കഴിഞ്ഞില്ല.

ഇത്ര വലിയ വ്യവസായിയായിട്ടും പ്രമുഖരുമായി വിലമതിക്കുന്ന സൗഹൃദങ്ങള്‍ കാത്തുസൂക്ഷിച്ചിട്ടും ഫാരീസ്‌ അബൂബക്കറിന്റെ ഒരു ചിത്രം എവിടേയും ലഭ്യമല്ല. അതില്‍ ദുരൂഹതയുണ്ട്‌. അദ്ദേഹത്തിന്റെ സ്ഥാപനങ്ങളിലോ വെബ്‌സൈറ്റിലോ അത്‌ ലഭ്യമല്ല. ദീപികയില്‍വെച്ച്‌ അദ്ദേഹത്തിന്റെ ചിത്രമെടുത്ത ഫോട്ടോഗ്രാഫര്‍ക്ക്‌ കണക്കിന്‌ കിട്ടിയിരുന്നു. ഒടുവില്‍ മാര്‍ വര്‍ക്കി വിതയത്തിലുമായി കരാര്‍ ഒപ്പിടുന്ന വേളയില്‍ മൊബൈല്‍ ഫോണില്‍ ചിത്രമെടുത്ത വൈദികന്റെ പക്കല്‍നിന്ന്‌ അതും പിടിച്ചുവാങ്ങി നശിപ്പിച്ചിരുന്നു. കാഞ്ഞിരപ്പള്ളി ബിഷപ്പിന്റെ കീഴിലുള്ള ഒരു സ്‌കൂളിന്റെ ലൈബ്രറി കെട്ടിടത്തിന്‌ കല്ലിടുന്ന അത്ര വ്യക്തമല്ലാത്ത ഒരു ചിത്രം മാത്രമാണ്‌ ആകെ ലഭ്യമായിട്ടുള്ളത്‌.

നായനാര്‍ ഫുട്‌ബോള്‍: പണം വാങ്ങിയത്‌ അന്വേഷിക്കും -വി.എസ്‌.

മാതൃഭൂമി, ജൂലൈ 26

തിരുവനന്തപുരം: മുന്‍ മുഖ്യമന്ത്രി ഇ.കെ.നായനാരുടെ സ്‌മരണയ്‌ക്കായി സി.പി.എം. നേതൃത്വം മുന്‍കൈയെടുത്ത്‌ കണ്ണൂരില്‍ സംഘടിപ്പിച്ച ഫുട്‌ബോള്‍ മേളയ്‌ക്ക്‌ കളങ്കിതരില്‍ നിന്ന്‌ പണം വാങ്ങിയെന്ന ആരോപണത്തെക്കുറിച്ച്‌ അന്വേഷിക്കുമെന്ന്‌ മുഖ്യമന്ത്രി വി.എസ്‌.അച്യുതാനന്ദന്‍ പറഞ്ഞു.

ഈ പ്രശ്‌നം തന്റെ ശ്രദ്ധയില്‍ പെട്ടിട്ടില്ലെന്ന്‌ മന്ത്രിസഭാ യോഗത്തിനുശേഷം നടന്ന പത്രസമ്മേളനത്തില്‍ ചോദ്യത്തിനു മറുപടിയായി അദ്ദേഹം പറഞ്ഞു. കളങ്കിതരായവരില്‍ നിന്ന്‌ പണം വാങ്ങിയതായി കാണുന്നുമില്ല. എന്നാല്‍ ആരോപണം ഉണ്ടായ സ്ഥിതിക്ക്‌ അന്വേഷിക്കും.

എന്നാല്‍ ഫുട്‌ബോള്‍ സംഘാടകസമിതി ജനറല്‍ കണ്‍വീനര്‍ എം.വി.ഗോവിന്ദന്‍ പുറപ്പെടുവിച്ച പ്രസ്‌താവനയില്‍ ഇതുസംബന്ധിച്ച പത്രവാര്‍ത്ത നിഷേധിച്ചില്ലെന്ന്‌ ചൂണ്ടിക്കാണിച്ചപ്പോഴാണ്‌ അന്വേഷണം നടത്താമെന്ന്‌ മുഖ്യമന്ത്രി പറഞ്ഞത്‌.

ഫുട്ബോള്‍ മേളയ്ക്ക് 60 ലക്ഷം സംഭാവന നല്‍കിയ വ്യവസായിയുടെ പശ്ചാത്തലം സി. പി. എമ്മിന് തലവേദന

മാതൃഭൂമി ജൂലൈ 26

തിരുവനന്തപുരം: ഇ. കെ. നായനാരുടെ പേരില്‍ സി. പി. എം. സംഘടിപ്പിച്ച ഫുട്‌ബോള്‍ മേളയ്‌ക്ക്‌ 60 ലക്ഷം രൂപ 'സംഭാവന' നല്‍കിയ വ്യവസായിയുടെ പശ്ചാത്തലം പാര്‍ട്ടിക്ക്‌ തലവേദനയാകുന്നു.

സിംഗപ്പൂരില്‍ നാഷണല്‍ കിഡ്‌നി ഫൗണ്ടേഷന്‍ കുംഭകോണത്തില്‍ പ്രതിയാവുകയും കുറ്റം സമ്മതിച്ച്‌ പിഴയടക്കുകയും ചെയ്‌ത ഒരു വ്യവസായിയില്‍ നിന്നും ജനകീയ നേതാവായിരുന്ന നായനാരുടെ പേരിലുള്ള സംരംഭത്തിന്‌ പണം പറ്റിയത്‌ വിശദീകരിക്കാനാകാത്തതാണ്‌ നേതാക്കളുടെ പുതിയ പ്രതിസന്ധി. കുംഭകോണത്തില്‍ പ്രതിയായ വ്യവസായിയുമായി പാര്‍ട്ടിയിലെ ഉന്നത നേതാക്കള്‍ക്കുള്ള ബന്ധത്തിലെ ദുരൂഹതയും ഇതോടൊപ്പം ചര്‍ച്ച ചെയ്യപ്പെടുന്നു.

ഫുട്‌ബോള്‍ ടൂര്‍ണമെന്റിന്‌ ചെന്നൈ ആസ്ഥാനമായ 'പാരറ്റ്‌ ഗ്രോവ്‌' എന്ന സ്ഥാപനമാണ്‌ 60 ലക്ഷം രൂപ നല്‍കിയത്‌. എന്നാല്‍ ടൂര്‍ണമെന്റിന്റെ സ്‌പോണ്‍സര്‍മാരായി ഈ സ്ഥാപനം രംഗത്തുവരാതെ നിഷ്‌കാമ കര്‍മ്മ'മായിട്ടായിരുന്നു സംഭാവന. വ്യവസായിയും 'ദീപിക' ചെയര്‍മാനുമായ എം. എ. ഫാരീസിന്റെതാണ്‌ ഈ സ്ഥാപനം.

നാഷണല്‍ കിഡ്‌നി ഫൗണ്ടേഷനുമായി ബന്ധപ്പെട്ട കുംഭകോണത്തില്‍ 10 ലക്ഷം ഡോളര്‍ (ഏകദേശം 40 കോടി രൂപ) നഷ്ടപരിഹാരം ആവശ്യപ്പെട്ടാണ്‌ സിങ്കപ്പൂര്‍ ഹൈക്കോടതിയില്‍ ഫാരീസ്‌ അബൂബേക്കര്‍ ഉള്‍പ്പെടെ അഞ്ചുപേര്‍ പ്രതികളായി കേസ്‌ ചാര്‍ജ്ജ്‌ ചെയ്യപ്പെട്ടിരുന്നത്‌. നാഷണല്‍ കിഡ്‌നി ഫൗണ്ടേഷന്റെ സി. ഇ. ഒ. ശ്രീലങ്കന്‍ തമിഴ്‌ വംശജനായ ടി. ടി. ദുരൈ, മുന്‍ ഭരണസമിതി അംഗങ്ങളായിരുന്ന റിച്ചാര്‍ഡ്‌ യങ്‌, ലൂലോസാന്‍, മറ്റില്‍ഡാചുവ എന്നിവരായിരുന്നു മറ്റു പ്രതികള്‍.

കേസ്സിന്റെ വിചാരണ തുടങ്ങി മൂന്നാം ദിവസം തന്നെ ടി. ടി. ദുരൈ കുറ്റം സമ്മതിച്ച്‌ പിന്‍വാങ്ങി. ഫാരീസ്‌ അബൂബേക്കര്‍ ഉള്‍പ്പെടെ മറ്റ്‌ നാല്‌ പ്രതികളും 2007 ഫിബ്രവരിയോടെ തുക മുഴുവനും കോടതി ചെലവുകള്‍ സഹിതം നല്‍കി കേസ്സില്‍ നിന്ന്‌ തടിയൂരുകയായിരുന്നു. എന്‍.കെ. എഫിന്റെ പുതിയ ചെയര്‍മാനായ ജെറാള്‍ഡ്‌ പുറത്തിറക്കിയ പത്രക്കുറിപ്പിലൂടെ ഈ വിവരം കമ്പനി ലോകത്തെ അറിയിക്കുകയും ചെയ്‌തു.

കിഡ്‌നി രോഗികള്‍ക്ക്‌ കുറഞ്ഞ ചെലവില്‍ ചികിത്സ നല്‍കുകയെന്ന ലക്ഷ്യത്തോടെ സിങ്കപ്പൂരില്‍ പ്രവര്‍ത്തിച്ചുവന്ന സ്ഥാപനമാണ്‌ നാഷണല്‍ കിഡ്‌നി ഫൗണ്ടേഷന്‍. ജനങ്ങളില്‍ നിന്നുള്ള സംഭാവനയായിരുന്നു സ്ഥാപനത്തിന്റെ പ്രധാന മൂലധനം. സിങ്കപ്പൂര്‍ ജനതയുടെ അകമഴിഞ്ഞ സംഭാവനയില്‍ ഫൗണ്ടേഷന്‍ വളര്‍ന്നുപന്തലിച്ചു. 2000-04-ല്‍ കമ്പനിയുടെ മൊത്ത വരുമാനം 71 ലക്ഷത്തില്‍ നിന്ന്‌ 313 കോടിയായി ഉയര്‍ന്നു. കരുതല്‍ ധനം 1431 ലക്ഷം ഡോളറില്‍ നിന്ന്‌ 2406 ലക്ഷം ഡോളറായി. 2004-ല്‍ മാത്രം കമ്പനി സംഭാവനയായി ജനങ്ങളില്‍ നിന്ന്‌ പിരിച്ചെടുത്തത്‌ 700 ലക്ഷം ഡോളറായിരുന്നു (280 കോടിയോളം രൂപ).

2005 ജൂലായിലാണ്‌ എന്‍.കെ. എഫ്‌. കുംഭകോണം പൊട്ടിപ്പുറപ്പെട്ടത്‌. സി. ഇ. ഒ. ആയിരുന്ന ടി. ടി. ദുരൈയുടെ ഓഫീസില്‍ സ്വര്‍ണ്ണം പൂശിയ ടാപ്പും വിലകൂടിയ ജര്‍മ്മന്‍ ടോയ്‌ലറ്റ്‌ ബൗളും ഘടിപ്പിച്ചുവെന്ന ആക്ഷേപമാണ്‌ തട്ടിപ്പ്‌ പുറത്തുകൊണ്ടുവരുന്നതിന്‌ നിമിത്തമായത്‌. ഈ വിവരം പ്രസിദ്ധീകരിച്ച സിങ്കപ്പൂരിലെ പത്രത്തിനെതിരെ ആദ്യം മാനനഷ്ടക്കേസ്‌ കമ്പനി നല്‍കിയെങ്കിലും കൂടുതല്‍ തട്ടിപ്പുകള്‍ പുറത്തുവരാനേ അത്‌ ഉപകരിച്ചുള്ളൂ.

2005 ജൂലായില്‍ തന്നെ ദുരൈയും മറ്റ്‌ ഡയറക്ടര്‍ ബോര്‍ഡ്‌ അംഗങ്ങളും രാജിവെച്ചു. പുതിയ ഭരണസമിതി പ്രശസ്‌ത അക്കൗണ്ടിങ്‌ സ്ഥാപനമായ കെ. പി. എം. ജി. യെ ഓഡിറ്റ്‌ ഏല്‌പിച്ചു. ഇവരുടെ പരിശോധനയിലാണ്‌ ഫാരീസ്‌ അബൂബക്കറും പ്രതിസ്ഥാനത്തേയ്‌ക്ക്‌ വന്നത്‌.

ദുരൈയുടെ അടുത്ത സുഹൃത്തായ ഫാരീസ്‌ അബൂബക്കര്‍ ഡയറക്ടറായ ഫോര്‍ട്ടെസിസ്റ്റം, പ്രോട്ടോണ്‍ വെബ്‌ എന്നി ഐ. ടി. കമ്പനികള്‍ക്ക്‌ 13.8 കോടിയുടെയും 18.4 കോടിയുടെയും കരാറുകള്‍ നല്‍കി. എന്നാല്‍ ഏറ്റെടുത്ത ജോലികള്‍ കമ്പനികള്‍ ചെയ്‌തില്ല. എങ്കിലും എന്‍. കെ. എഫ്‌. ഈ കമ്പനികള്‍ക്ക്‌ പണം നല്‍കി. ക്രമംവിട്ട്‌ കരാര്‍ നല്‍കുകയും വ്യവസ്ഥ പാലിക്കാഞ്ഞിട്ടും ഫാരീസിന്റെ ഇന്ത്യയിലേയ്‌ക്കുള്ള കമ്പനിയുടെ അക്കൗണ്ടിലേക്ക്‌ വരെ പണം കൈമാറുകയും ചെയ്‌തത്‌ ഓഡിറ്റ്‌ റിപ്പോര്‍ട്ടില്‍ എണ്ണമിട്ട്‌ പറയുന്നുണ്ട്‌. എന്‍. കെ. എഫുമായി ബിസിനസ്‌ ബന്ധമുണ്ടായിരുന്ന ഫാരീസിന്റെ നാല്‌ കമ്പനികള്‍ വഴിയായിരുന്നു തട്ടിപ്പ്‌ അരങ്ങേറിയത്‌.

നഷ്ടപരിഹാരത്തുക പൂര്‍ണ്ണമായി നല്‍കിയതിലൂടെ കുറ്റസമ്മതം നടത്തി ഫാരീസ്‌ കേസ്സില്‍ നിന്ന്‌ ഒഴിവാകുകയായിരുന്നു. തുടര്‍ന്ന്‌ 'ദീപിക' ദിനപത്രം ഫാരീസ്‌ വാങ്ങി. ഇതോടെ സി. പി. എം. വിഭാഗീയതയില്‍ ഔദ്യോഗിക പക്ഷത്തിന്റെ പ്രചാരണ ആയുധമായി അത്‌ മാറി. ഈ സാഹചര്യത്തിലാണ്‌ സാമ്പത്തിക തട്ടിപ്പില്‍ പ്രതിയായി കുറ്റസമ്മതം നടത്തി നഷ്ടപരിഹാരത്തുക നല്‍കിയ കേസിലെ പ്രതിയുമായി സി. പി.എം. നേതാക്കള്‍ക്കുള്ള ബന്ധം വിശദീകരിക്കാനാകാതെ നേതൃത്വം കുഴയുന്നത്‌.
 

blogger templates | Make Money Online